Abstract:Cosmic ray (CR) knees (spectral steepenings) encode information on CR accelerator populations. We seek population features that imprint onto knee observables in a manner that is robust enough to be discernible even in the presence of significant systematics in CR data. In particular, we explore how diversity among population members could imprint on the knee phenomenology, under the assumption that a knee is due to a fixed-rigidity cutoff in the source spectra. We use a simple theoretical model for a population of CR accelerators. Each population member accelerates CR to a power-law spectrum, up to a cutoff rigidity. We allow for variance among members, in cutoff rigidity and power-law slope. We find that: (a) the slope step of the spectrum is $\sim 0.5$, decreasing weakly with increasing spread in either property; (b) composition always breaks first; (c) the difference between the break energies in composition and flux increases with increasing diversity; (d) composition and flux break together only if population diversity is minimal. These trends are robust under our assumptions; deviations from them would indicate more complex physics than encoded in our simple model. Comparing these trends with observed CR knees, we conclude that: (i) the primary knee at $\sim 4\times10^{15}$ eV is consistent with a constant-rigidity cutoff according to KASCADE-Grande data processed with post-LHC hadronic models, but not according to other datasets; (ii) the second knee at $\sim 5 \times 10^{17}$ eV requires more complexity than our model; (iii) the spectral feature identified by Auger at $\sim 10^{19}$ eV is consistent with a constant-rigidity source cutoff only if there is a substantial spread in both cutoff rigidity and slope. Interestingly, a significant spread in slope would also result in spectral curvature before the break, which would in turn be contributing to the ankle feature.

Two approaches to the cosmic ray "knee" problem and the experimental data

Models for the origin of the knee in the cosmic-ray spectrum

The composition of cosmic rays according to the data on EAS cores

Reconciling the light component and all-particle cosmic ray energy spectra at the knee

The Origin of the Knee in the Cosmic-Ray Energy Spectrum

Model of Cosmic Ray Propagation in the Milky Way at the Knee

What can cosmic-ray knees reveal about source populations?

Cosmic ray composition and energy spectrum above 1 TeV: direct and EAS measurements

Energy dependence of the knee in the cosmic ray spectrum across the Milky Way

Overview on direct and indirect measurements of cosmic rays - Some thoughts on galactic cosmic rays and the knee

A study on the sharp knee and fine structures of cosmic ray spectra

An anti-knee

The end of the galactic cosmic-ray energy spectrum - a phenomenological view

Why the knee at 100 PeV could not be seen?

Where are the Pevatrons that Form the Knee in the Spectrum of the Cosmic Ray Nucleon Component around 4 PeV?

Expectation on probing the origin of the cosmic ray knee with the LHAASO experiment

X-ray Spectropolarimetric Measurements of the Kerr Metric

The Knee and the Second Knee of the Cosmic-Ray Energy Spectrum

Energy Spectrum and Mass Composition around the Knee by EAS Measurements

Galactic Basins of Helium and Iron around the Knee Energy

Ankle Phenomenon in the Cosmic Ray Energy Spectrum