Overview on direct and indirect measurements of cosmic rays - Some thoughts on galactic cosmic rays and the knee

Joerg R. Hoerandel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/S0217751X05030016

2005-01-13

Abstract:An overview is given on results from direct and indirect measurements of galactic cosmic rays. Their implications on the contemporary understanding of the origin of cosmic rays and the knee in their energy spectrum are discussed.

Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Cosmic-ray composition and its relation to shock acceleration by supernova remnants

Joerg R. Hoerandel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.asr.2007.06.008

2007-06-05

Abstract:An overview is given on the present status of the understanding of the origin of galactic cosmic rays. Recent measurements of charged cosmic rays and photons are reviewed. Their impact on the contemporary knowledge about the sources and acceleration mechanisms of cosmic rays and their propagation through the Galaxy is discussed. Possible reasons for the knee in the energy spectrum and scenarios for the end of the galactic cosmic-ray component are described.

Astrophysics
Models for the origin of the knee in the cosmic-ray spectrum

A.D. Erlykin,A.W. Wolfendale

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0273-1177(01)00125-9

IF: 2.611

2001-01-01

Advances in Space Research

Abstract:A sudden steepening of the cosmic-ray energy spectrum (the knee) is observed at an energy of about 3 PeV (1 PeV = 1015eV). The experimental study of the PeV cosmic rays has intensified greatly during the last 3 years. The recent results on extensive air showers allow us to conclude that: a) the knee has an astrophysical origin; b) the ‘sharpness’ and the fine structure of the knee rule out ‘Galactic Modulation’ as the origin of the knee; c) most likely the knee is the result of the explosion of a single, recent, nearby supernova.

geosciences, multidisciplinary,meteorology & atmospheric sciences,astronomy & astrophysics,engineering, aerospace
Energy dependence of the knee in the cosmic ray spectrum across the Milky Way

C. Prevotat,M. Kachelriess,S. Koldobskiy,A. Neronov,D. Semikoz

2024-10-04

Abstract:The all-particle spectrum of cosmic rays measured at Earth has a knee-like feature around 4 PeV. A priori, it is not clear if this is a local feature specific to the Solar neighbourhood in the Milky Way, or if it is a generic property of the Galactic cosmic-ray spectrum. We argue that combining gamma-ray and cosmic-ray data of LHAASO indicates that the knee is a local feature. In order to demonstrate this, we derive a model for the local cosmic-ray spectrum and composition, consistent with the recent LHAASO measurements of the all-particle spectrum and the mean logarithmic mass in the knee region. We calculate the spectrum of diffuse gamma-ray emission based on this model and find that the expected spectral shape of the diffuse gamma-ray flux disagrees with the LHAASO measurements of the diffuse gamma-ray emission in the 10-100 TeV energy range in the inner and outer Galaxy. We determine the break energy in the CR spectrum expected from these gamma-ray data and find it an energy ten times lower than obtained from local measurements.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena,High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
Cosmic ray composition and energy spectrum above 1 TeV: direct and EAS measurements

A. Castellina

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0920-5632(01)01182-3

2001-04-01

Abstract:The most recent experimental results on the cosmic ray composition and energy spectrum above 1 TeV are reviewed and discussed. All data agree on the presence of the so-called “knee” at an energy Eκ ⋍ 3 1015eV; the knee is seen in all the components of the Extensive Air Showers. These results support the hypothesis of an astrophysical origin of the knee, while no new features in the hadronic interactions at high energies are envisaged. The cosmic ray composition below and above the knee region is still an open question. According to most experiments, the knee seems to be due to the light component of the primary beam, with a composition getting heavier above the knee. However, results contradicting this conclusion have to be considered and understood.
Astrophysics of the Knee in the Cosmic Ray Energy Spectrum

A. Haungs et al.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.astro-ph/0312295

2003-12-11

Abstract:A brief review is given on the astrophysics of cosmic rays in the PeV primary energy range, i.e. the region of the knee.

Astrophysics
The end of the galactic cosmic-ray energy spectrum - a phenomenological view

Joerg R. Hoerandel,N.N. Kalmykov,A.V. Timokhin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/47/1/017

2005-07-31

Abstract:Two structures in the all-particle energy spectrum of cosmic rays, the knee at 4 PeV and the second knee around 400 PeV are proposed to be explained by a phenomenological model, the poly gonato model, connecting direct and indirect measurements. Within this approach the knee is caused by a successive cut-off of the flux for individual elements starting with protons at 4.5 PeV. The second knee is interpreted as the end of the stable nuclei of the periodic table. To check some key features of this model calculations of the cosmic ray energy spectrum and the propagation path length at energies from 10^14 to 10^19 eV have been performed within the framework of a combined approach based on the diffusion model of cosmic rays and a direct simulation of charged-particle trajectories in the Galaxy.

Astrophysics
Measurement of Energy Spectrum and Elemental Composition of PeV Cosmic Rays: Open Problems and Prospects

G. Di Sciascio

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2202.11618

2022-02-23

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena

Abstract:Cosmic rays represent one of the most important energy transformation processes of the universe. They bring information about the surrounding universe, our galaxy, and very probably also the extragalactic space, at least at the highest observed energies. More than one century after their discovery, we have no definitive models yet about the origin, acceleration and propagation processes of the radiation. The main reason is that there are still significant discrepancies among the results obtained by different experiments located at ground level, probably due to unknown systematic uncertainties affecting the measurements. In this document, we will focus on the detection of galactic cosmic rays from ground with air shower arrays up to 10$^{18}$ eV. The aim of this paper is to discuss the conflicting results in the 10$^{15}$ eV energy range and the perspectives to clarify the origin of the so-called `knee' in the all-particle energy spectrum, crucial to give a solid basis for models up to the end of the cosmic ray spectrum. We will provide elements useful to understand the basic techniques used in reconstructing primary particle characteristics (energy, mass, and arrival direction) from the ground, and to show why indirect measurements are difficult and results are still conflicting.
The Origin of the Knee in the Cosmic-Ray Energy Spectrum

A.D.Erlykin,A.W.Wolfendale

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.astro-ph/0103477

2001-05-20

Abstract:A sudden steepening of the cosmic-ray energy spectrum (the knee) is observed at an energy of about 3 PeV (1 PeV = 10$^{15}$eV). The recent results on extensive air showers allow us to conclude that: a) the knee has an astrophysical origin; b) the 'sharpness' and the fine structure of the knee rule out 'Galactic Modulation' as the origin of the knee; c) most likely the knee is the result of the explosion of a single, recent, nearby supernova.

Astrophysics
Model of Cosmic Ray Propagation in the Milky Way at the Knee

G. Giacinti,D. Semikoz

2023-05-17

Abstract:We present a new model of anisotropic cosmic ray propagation in the Milky Way, where cosmic rays are injected at discrete transient sources in the disc and propagated in the Galactic magnetic field. In the framework of our model, we show that the cosmic ray spectrum is time-dependent and space-dependent around the energy of the knee. It has a major contribution of one or a few nearby recent sources at any given location in the Galaxy, in particular at the position of the Solar system. We find that the distribution of $\sim$ PeV cosmic rays in our Galaxy is significantly clumpy and inhomogeneous, and therefore substantially different from the smoother distribution of GeV cosmic rays. Our findings have important implications for the calculation and future interpretation of the diffuse Galactic gamma-ray and neutrino fluxes at very high energies.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena
What Do We Expect to Learn from Very High Energy Cosmic Ray Observations?

H. Rebel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.astro-ph/0109520

2001-09-27

Astrophysics

Abstract:By a short tour through the exciting field of very high-energy and ultra high-energy cosmic rays studies, a brief review is given about the current questions approached, in particular by the KASCADE experiment and the Pierre Auger project. The present status of the investigations of the knee region of the cosmic ray spectrum by KASCADE is presented and open problems are discussed.
Two approaches to the cosmic ray "knee" problem and the experimental data

Yuri V. Stenkin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.astro-ph/0507018

2005-07-01

Astrophysics

Abstract:Two approaches to the old problem of the so-called "knee" in cosmic ray spectrum are compared with the existing experimental data. It is shown that "standard astrophysical model" of the knee is not supported by some experimental data, while the alternative model agrees better with the data.
Constraining the Position of the Knee in the Galactic Cosmic-Ray Spectrum with Ultra-high-energy Diffuse γ-Rays

Pei-Pei Zhang,Yi-Qing Guo,Bing-Qiang Qiao,Wei Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ac98ff

2022-11-15

Abstract:The diffuse γ-ray emission was measured up to 957 TeV by the Tibet-ASγ experiment recently. Assuming that it is produced by the hadronic interaction between cosmic-ray nuclei and the interstellar medium, it requires that the cosmic-ray nuclei should be accelerated well beyond PeV energies. Measurements of the cosmic-ray spectra for different species show diverse results at present. The Tibet experiments showed that the spectrum of proton plus helium has an early knee below PeV. If this is correct, the diffuse γ-ray emission would suggest an additional component of Galactic cosmic rays above PeV energies. This second component may originate from a source population of so-called PeVatrons revealed by recent ultra-high-energy γ-ray observations and could contribute to the cosmic-ray fluxes up to the energy of the second knee. On the other hand, the KASCADE measurement showed that the knee of protons is higher than PeV. In this case, the diffuse γ-rays observed by Tibet-ASγ can be well accounted for by only one cosmic-ray component. These two scenarios (i.e., the Tibet and KASCADE knees) could be distinguished by the spectral structures of diffuse γ-rays and cosmic-ray nuclei. Future measurements of spectra of individual nuclei by HERD and LHAASO experiments and diffuse γ-rays by LHAASO can jointly constrain these two scenarios.

astronomy & astrophysics
Detection of Cosmic Rays from ground: an Introduction

Giuseppe Di Sciascio

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/1263/1/012002

2019-06-01

Journal of Physics: Conference Series

Abstract:Abstract Cosmic rays are the most outstanding example of accelerated particles. They are about 1% of the total mass of the Universe, so that cosmic rays would represent by far the most important energy transformation process of the Universe. Despite large progresses in building new detectors and in the analysis techniques, the key questions concerning origin, acceleration and propagation of the radiation are still open. One of the reasons is that there are significant discrepancies among the different results obtained by experiments located at ground probably due to unknown systematic errors affecting the measurements. In this note we will focus on detection of Galactic CRs from ground with EAS arrays. This is not a place for a complete review of CR physics (for which we recommend, for instance [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7]) but only to provide elements useful to understand the basic techniques used in reconstructing primary particle characteristics (energy, mass and arrival direction) from ground, and to show why indirect measurements are difficult and results still conflicting.
Energy Spectrum and Mass Composition around the Knee by EAS Measurements

A.Haungs

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0954-3899/29/5/303

2002-12-20

Abstract:Primary cosmic ray particles above energies of about 100 TeV are investigated by large-area ground based detector installations, observing various components of the development of extensive air-showers (EAS). By such an indirect access to the primary cosmic ray spectrum a steepening of the power-law falls off at around 3-5 PeV, known as the {\em knee} has been identified. Different experimental techniques are used to deduce mass- and energy-sensitive observables of EAS experiments. The experiments involve measurements of secondary particle distributions at various observation levels and of muons deep underground as well as of observables reconstructed by measuring the air Cherenkov light emitted with the shower development in the atmosphere. Recently methods for analysing multidimensional distributions get favoured since they are able to take into account the correlations between different observables and the influence of large intrinsic fluctuations of the air-shower development. Additionally the use of a larger set of observables provides the possibility to test simultaneously the consistency of the Monte-Carlo models underlying the reconstruction procedures. By many experiments the existence of the knee in the primary energy spectrum is confirmed and a tendency of an increasing mean mass above the knee energy is indicated. Recent results show that the knee originates from a decrease of the flux of light primary particles, whereas heavy cosmic ray particles seem to miss a kink in the energy range of 1 and 10 PeV.

Astrophysics
Galactic Basins of Helium and Iron around the Knee Energy

Antonio Codino,Francois Plouin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.astro-ph/0701498

2007-01-17

Astrophysics

Abstract:The differential energy spectrum of cosmic rays exhibits a change of slope, called "knee" of the spectrum, around the nominal energy of 3 x 10^15 eV, and individual "knees" for single ions, at different energies. The present work reports a detailed account of the characteristics and the origin of the knees for Helium and Iron. Current observational data regarding the magnetic field, the insterstellar matter density, the size of the Galaxy and the galactic wind, are incorporated in appropriate algorithms which allow to simulate millions of cosmic-ion trajectories in the disk. Bundles of ion trajectories define galactic regions called basins utilized in the present analysis of the knees. The fundamental role of the nuclear cross sections in the origin of the helium and iron knees is demonstrated and highlighted. The results of the calculation are compared with the experimental data in the energy interval 10^12 eV - 5 x 10^17 eV. There is a fair agreement between the computed and measured energy spectra of Helium and Iron; rather surprisingly their relative intensities are also in accord with those computed here. The results suggest that acceleration mechanisms in the disk are extraneous to the origin of the "knees".
A revamped understanding of Cosmic Rays and Gamma-Ray Bursts

A. De Rújula

2024-11-24

Abstract:Interesting data on Gamma Ray Burts (GRBs) and Cosmic Rays (CRs) have recently been made public. GRB221009A has a record ``peak energy". The CR electron spectrum has been measured to unprecedented high energies and exhibits a ``knee" akin to the ones in all-particle or individual-element CR nuclei. IceCube has not seen high-energy neutrinos associated with GRBs. AMS has published a CR positron spectrum conducive to much speculation. We examine these data in the light of the ``CannonBall Model" of GRBs and CRs, in which they are intimately related and which they do strongly validate.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
Cosmic Rays and Particle Physics

Karl-Heinz Kampert

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1556/APH.14.2001.1-4.20

2001-01-19

Abstract:The study of high energy cosmic rays is a diversified field of observational and phenomenological physics addressing questions ranging from shock acceleration of charged particles in various astrophysical objects, via transport properties through galactic and extragalactic space, to questions of dark matter, and even to those of particle physics beyond the Standard Model including processes taking place in the earliest moments of our Universe. After decades of mostly independent evolution of nuclear-, particle- and high energy cosmic ray physics we find ourselves entering a symbiotic era of these fields of research. Some examples of interrelations will be given from the perspective of modern Particle-Astrophysics and new major experiments will briefly be sketched.

Astrophysics,High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
What can cosmic-ray knees reveal about source populations?

Myrto Falalaki,Vasiliki Pavlidou

2024-04-23

Abstract:Cosmic ray (CR) knees (spectral steepenings) encode information on CR accelerator populations. We seek population features that imprint onto knee observables in a manner that is robust enough to be discernible even in the presence of significant systematics in CR data. In particular, we explore how diversity among population members could imprint on the knee phenomenology, under the assumption that a knee is due to a fixed-rigidity cutoff in the source spectra. We use a simple theoretical model for a population of CR accelerators. Each population member accelerates CR to a power-law spectrum, up to a cutoff rigidity. We allow for variance among members, in cutoff rigidity and power-law slope. We find that: (a) the slope step of the spectrum is $\sim 0.5$, decreasing weakly with increasing spread in either property; (b) composition always breaks first; (c) the difference between the break energies in composition and flux increases with increasing diversity; (d) composition and flux break together only if population diversity is minimal. These trends are robust under our assumptions; deviations from them would indicate more complex physics than encoded in our simple model. Comparing these trends with observed CR knees, we conclude that: (i) the primary knee at $\sim 4\times10^{15}$ eV is consistent with a constant-rigidity cutoff according to KASCADE-Grande data processed with post-LHC hadronic models, but not according to other datasets; (ii) the second knee at $\sim 5 \times 10^{17}$ eV requires more complexity than our model; (iii) the spectral feature identified by Auger at $\sim 10^{19}$ eV is consistent with a constant-rigidity source cutoff only if there is a substantial spread in both cutoff rigidity and slope. Interestingly, a significant spread in slope would also result in spectral curvature before the break, which would in turn be contributing to the ankle feature.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena
Experimental Summary: Very High Energy Cosmic Rays and their Interactions

Karl-Heinz Kampert

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1305.2348

2013-05-10

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena

Abstract:The XVII International Symposium on Very High Energy Cosmic Ray Interactions, held in August of 2012 in Berlin, was the first one in the history of the Symposium, where a plethora of high precision LHC data with relevance for cosmic ray physics was presented. This report aims at giving a brief summary of those measurements and it discusses their relevance for observations of high energy cosmic rays. Enormous progress has been made also in air shower observations and in direct measurements of cosmic rays, exhibiting many more structure in the cosmic ray energy spectrum than just a simple power law with a knee and an ankle. At the highest energy, the flux suppression may not be dominated by the GZK-effect but by the limiting energy of a nearby source or source population. New projects and application of new technologies promise further advances also in the near future. We shall discuss the experimental and theoretical progress in the field and its prospects for coming years.
The Knee and the Second Knee of the Cosmic-Ray Energy Spectrum

T. Abu-Zayyad,D. Ivanov,C. C. H. Jui,J. H. Kim,J. N. Matthews,J. D. Smith,S. B. Thomas,G. B. Thomson,Z. Zundel,C.C.H. Jui,J.H. Kim,J.N. Matthews,J.D. Smith,S.B. Thomas,G.B. Thomson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1803.07052

2018-03-19

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena

Abstract:The cosmic ray flux measured by the Telescope Array Low Energy Extension (TALE) exhibits three spectral features: the knee, the dip in the $10^{16}$ eV decade, and the second knee. Here the spectrum has been measured for the first time using fluorescence telescopes, which provide a calorimetric, model-independent result. The spectrum appears to be a rigidity-dependent cutoff sequence, where the knee is made by the hydrogen and helium portions of the composition, the dip comes from the reduction in composition from helium to metals, the rise to the second knee occurs due to intermediate range nuclei, and the second knee is the iron knee.

Overview on direct and indirect measurements of cosmic rays - Some thoughts on galactic cosmic rays and the knee

Cosmic-ray composition and its relation to shock acceleration by supernova remnants

Models for the origin of the knee in the cosmic-ray spectrum

Energy dependence of the knee in the cosmic ray spectrum across the Milky Way

Cosmic ray composition and energy spectrum above 1 TeV: direct and EAS measurements

Astrophysics of the Knee in the Cosmic Ray Energy Spectrum

The end of the galactic cosmic-ray energy spectrum - a phenomenological view

Measurement of Energy Spectrum and Elemental Composition of PeV Cosmic Rays: Open Problems and Prospects

The Origin of the Knee in the Cosmic-Ray Energy Spectrum

Model of Cosmic Ray Propagation in the Milky Way at the Knee

What Do We Expect to Learn from Very High Energy Cosmic Ray Observations?

Two approaches to the cosmic ray "knee" problem and the experimental data

Constraining the Position of the Knee in the Galactic Cosmic-Ray Spectrum with Ultra-high-energy Diffuse γ-Rays

Detection of Cosmic Rays from ground: an Introduction

Energy Spectrum and Mass Composition around the Knee by EAS Measurements

Galactic Basins of Helium and Iron around the Knee Energy

A revamped understanding of Cosmic Rays and Gamma-Ray Bursts

Cosmic Rays and Particle Physics

What can cosmic-ray knees reveal about source populations?

Experimental Summary: Very High Energy Cosmic Rays and their Interactions

The Knee and the Second Knee of the Cosmic-Ray Energy Spectrum