Characterization of the ATF y CREB site and its complex with GCN 4
S. C. Hockings,J. Kahn,D. Crothers
Abstract:We have studied DNA minicircles containing the ATFyCREB binding site for GCN4 by using a combination of cyclization kinetics experiments and Monte Carlo simulations. Cyclization rates were determined with and without GCN4 for DNA constructs containing the ATFyCREB site separated from a phased A-tract multimer bend by a variable length phasing adaptor. The cyclization results show that GCN4 binding does not significantly change the conformation of the ATFyCREB site, which is intrinsically slightly bent toward the major groove. Monte Carlo simulations quantitate the ATFyCREB site structure as an 8° bend toward the major groove in a coordinate frame near the center of the site. The ATFyCREB site is underwound by 53° relative to the related AP-1 site DNA. The effect of GCN4 binding can be modeled either as a decrease in the local f lexibility, corresponding to an estimated 60% increase in the persistence length for the 10-bp binding site, or possibly as a small decrease (1°) in intrinsic bend angle. Our results agree with recent electrophoretic and crystallographic studies and demonstrate that cyclization and simulation can characterize subtle changes in DNA structure and flexibility. Dimers of bZIP proteins bind dyad symmetric DNA binding sites including the AP-1 site, 59-ATGACTCAT-39, and the ATFyCREB site, 59-ATGACGTCAT-39. These two sites share the same 59-ATGA-39 half-site, but most bZIP proteins can discriminate between them based on the difference in half-site spacing, usually binding weakly or not at all to one of the sites. GCN4, a yeast transcriptional activator, is an exception because it binds the AP-1 and ATFyCREB sites with comparable affinity (1). GCN4, a 281-residue protein from Saccharomyces cerevisiae, activates amino acid biosynthetic pathways under amino acid starvation conditions (2, 3). The 9-bp AP-1 site is the functional binding site in vivo, but mutagenesis studies have shown that the central 7-bp site, 59-TGACTCA-39, is the preferentially recognized consensus (4, 5). Both the circular permutation and phasing gel mobility experiments were done with GCN4 and the AP-1 site (6). These two experiments gave contradictory results with the full-length protein, but the assays with bZIP peptide showed that it does not bend DNA. Recently, the same experiments were done on a bZIP peptide of GCN4 (the 55-aa peptide contains an N-terminal serine followed by residues 228–281) with both the AP-1 and ATFyCREB sites (7). For the AP-1 site, the DNA is straight, whereas for the ATFyCREB site, the DNA was found to be bent toward the major groove. Two different bZIP peptides derived from GCN4 have been cocrystallized with DNA, one with the AP-1 site and the other with the ATFyCREB site (8–10). The AP-1 site is not appreciably bent in a cocrystal with a 58-aa peptide. In contrast, the ATFyCREB site has an overall bend of about 20° when complexed to a similar 62-aa peptide. Both structures show the same protein–DNA contacts, which are possible because the bending of the ATFyCREB site in the complex creates a contact surface that resembles the AP-1 site. DNA bending can be studied in solution by DNA ring closure, which can measure the degree of an intrinsic or protein-induced DNA bend (refs. 11 and 12, and references therein). The experiments are sensitive to deformations in DNA that include bending, helical repeat length, and torsional and bending flexibility (12–14). We are able to further interpret the experimental results by using Monte Carlo simulations to refine the DNA structural model (11). The AP-1 site has been shown to be straight in solution by using cyclization kinetics (15). Furthermore, it remains straight when bound to the bZIP proteins FosyJun (15, 16) or GCN4 (ref. 17 and unpublished data). We have studied the ATFyCREB binding site phased against A-tract bends by using cyclization kinetics. In our experiments, the full-length GCN4 protein and the 58-aa bZIP peptide used in cocrystallization (10) behave indistinguishably. The ATFyCREB site molecules show a slight bend toward the major groove, both alone and bound to protein. The optimum cyclization length indicates a significantly decreased DNA torsion relative to the AP-1 site, in both the presence and absence of protein. There is a small but significant decrease in cyclization probability on protein binding, which is more pronounced for the out-of-phase molecules, due apparently to a small protein-induced stiffening of the DNA. Monte Carlo simulations of the ATFyCREB site allow quantitative characterization of a small intrinsic DNA bend and underwinding across the site, relative to the AP-1 site. We conclude that GCN4 is able to bind the existing conformation of the site with no significant distortion, in agreement with Paolella et al. (7). MATERIALS AND METHODS GCN4. GCN4 was purified as described (6) from cells generously provided by Christophe Ampe and Tom Steitz (Yale Univ.) and was stored at 270°C at 25 mM in 20 mM Tris, pH 8.0y1 mM EDTAy50 mM KCly10 mM DTTy50% glycerol. A 58-residue bZIP peptide containing the C-terminal 56 residues of GCN4 preceded by Met and Lys was generously provided by Tom Ellenberger (Harvard Medical School, Boston) and stored at 4°C at 2 mM in 20 mM Tris, pH 8.0y1 mM EDTAy50 mM KCly50% glycerol (18). ATFyCREB Site Minicircles. The ATFyCREB site molecules were made in the same manner as the yeast AP-1 plasmids (15). The ATFyCREB molecules differ from the AP-1 molecules by one inserted GC bp in the binding site. The publication costs of this article were defrayed in part by page charge payment. This article must therefore be hereby marked ‘‘advertisement’’ in accordance with 18 U.S.C. §1734 solely to indicate this fact. © 1998 by The National Academy of Sciences 0027-8424y98y951410-6$2.00y0 PNAS is available online at http:yywww.pnas.org. Abbreviations: ABS, absolute error; REL, relative error; P, persistence length; C, torsional modulus. *Present address: Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742-2021. †To whom correspondence should be addressed at: Department of Chemistry, P.O. Box 208107, New Haven, CT 06520-8107. e-mail: Donald.Crothers@quickmail.yale.edu.