Abstract:Electroencephalography (EEG) is commonly used to examine neural activity time-locked to the presentation of a stimulus, referred to as an Event-Related Potential (ERP). However, EEG is also influenced by non-neural artifacts, which can confound ERP comparisons. Artifact cleaning can reduce artifacts, but often requires time-consuming manual decisions. Most automated cleaning methods require frequencies <1Hz to be filtered out of the data, so are not recommended for ERPs (which often contain <1Hz frequencies). In our companion article, we introduced RELAX (the Reduction of Electroencephalographic Artifacts), an automated and modular cleaning pipeline that reduces artifacts with Multiple Wiener Filtering (MWF) and/or wavelet enhanced independent component analysis (wICA) applied to artifact components detected with ICLabel (wICA_ICLabel) (Bailey et al., 2022). To evaluate the suitability of RELAX for data cleaning prior to ERP analysis, multiple versions of RELAX were compared to four commonly used EEG cleaning pipelines. Cleaning performance was compared across a range of artifact cleaning metrics and in the amount of variance in ERPs explained by different conditions in a Go-Nogo task. RELAX with MWF and wICA_ICLabel cleaned the data the most effectively and produced amongst the most dependable ERP estimates. RELAX with wICA_ICLabel only or MWF_only may detect experimental effects better for some ERP measures. Importantly, RELAX can high-pass filter data at 0.25Hz, so is applicable to analyses involving ERPs. The pipeline is easy to implement via EEGLAB in MATLAB and is freely available on GitHub. Given its performance, objectivity, and ease of use, we recommend RELAX for EEG data cleaning. The MATLAB code, the supplementary materials, and a simple instruction manual explaining how to implement the RELAX pipeline can be downloaded from https://github.com/NeilwBailey/RELAX/releases. A condition of use of the pipeline is that the version of the pipeline used is referred to as RELAX_[pipeline], for example “RELAX_MWF_wICA” or “RELAX_wICA_ICLabel”, and that the current paper be cited, as well as the dependencies used. These dependencies are likely to include: EEGLAB (Delorme & Makeig, 2004), fieldtrip (Oostenveld et al., 2011), the MWF toolbox (Somers et al., 2019), fastICA (Hyvarinen, 1999), wICA (Castellanos & Makarov, 2006), ICLabel (Pion-Tonachini et al., 2019), and PREP (Bigdely-Shamlo et al., 2015) See our companion article for the application of RELAX to the study of oscillatory power (Bailey et al., 2022).

EEG is better when cleaning effectively targets artifacts

Introducing RELAX (the Reduction of Electroencephalographic Artifacts): A fully automated pre-processing pipeline for cleaning EEG data - Part 1: Algorithm and Application to Oscillations

RELAX part 2: A fully automated EEG data cleaning algorithm that is applicable to Event-Related-Potentials

Introducing RELAX (the Reduction of Electroencephalographic Artifacts): A fully automated pre-processing pipeline for cleaning EEG data – Part 2: Application to Event-Related Potentials

State-of-the-art EEG artifact removal evaluation

Introducing RELAX: An automated pre-processing pipeline for cleaning EEG data - Part 1: Algorithm and Application to Oscillations

Artifacts Removing Techniques on EEG Waveforms

EEG artifact removal—state-of-the-art and guidelines

Removing Electroencephalographic Artifacts by Blind Source Separation

[Removal of Artifacts from EEG Signal].

How Much Data is Enough? Optimization of Data Collection for Artifact Detection in EEG Recordings

Identification and Removal of Physiological Artifacts From Electroencephalogram Signals: A Review

AnEEG: leveraging deep learning for effective artifact removal in EEG data

Extended ICA Removes Artifacts from Electroencephalographic Recordings

Improved artefact removal from EEG using Canonical Correlation Analysis and spectral slope

Fully automated unsupervised artefact removal in multichannel electroencephalogram using wavelet-independent component analysis with density-based spatial clustering of application with noise

Artefacts Removal to Detect Visual Evoked Potentials in Brain Computer Interface Systems

Evaluating the effectiveness of artifact correction and rejection in event‐related potential research

Improved rejection of artifacts from EEG data using high-order statistics and independent component analysis

Removal of Muscle Artifacts from the EEG: A Review and Recommendations

ARTIST: A fully automated artifact rejection algorithm for single‐pulse TMS‐EEG data