Abstract:Background: Improving clinical reasoning skills-the thought processes used by clinicians to formulate appropriate questions and diagnoses-is essential for reducing missed diagnostic opportunities. The electronic Clinical Reasoning Educational Simulation Tool (eCREST) was developed to improve the clinical reasoning of future physicians. A feasibility trial demonstrated acceptability and potential impacts; however, the processes by which students gathered data were unknown. Objective: This study aims to identify the data gathering patterns of final year medical students while using eCREST and how eCREST influences the patterns. Methods: A mixed methods design was used. A trial of eCREST across 3 UK medical schools (N=148) measured the potential effects of eCREST on data gathering. A qualitative think-aloud and semistructured interview study with 16 medical students from one medical school identified 3 data gathering strategies: Thorough, Focused, and Succinct. Some had no strategy. Reanalysis of the trial data identified the prevalence of data gathering patterns and compared patterns between the intervention and control groups. Patterns were identified based on 2 variables that were measured in a patient case 1 month after the intervention: the proportion of Essential information students identified and the proportion of irrelevant information gathered (Relevant). Those who scored in the top 3 quartiles for Essential but in the lowest quartile for Relevant displayed a Thorough pattern. Those who scored in the top 3 quartiles for Relevant but in the lowest quartile for Essential displayed a Succinct pattern. Those who scored in the top 3 quartiles on both variables displayed a Focused pattern. Those whose scores were in the lowest quartile on both variables displayed a Nonspecific pattern. Results: The trial results indicated that students in the intervention group were more thorough than those in the control groups when gathering data. The qualitative data identified data gathering strategies and the mechanisms by which eCREST influenced data gathering. Students reported that eCREST promoted thoroughness by prompting them to continuously reflect and allowing them to practice managing uncertainty. However, some found eCREST to be less useful, and they randomly gathered information. Reanalysis of the trial data revealed that the intervention group was significantly more likely to display a Thorough data gathering pattern than controls (21/78, 27% vs 6/70, 9%) and less likely to display a Succinct pattern (13/78, 17% vs 20/70, 29%; χ23=9.9; P=.02). Other patterns were similar across groups. Conclusions: Qualitative data suggested that students applied a range of data gathering strategies while using eCREST and that eCREST encouraged thoroughness by continuously prompting the students to reflect and manage their uncertainty. Trial data suggested that eCREST led students to demonstrate more Thorough data gathering patterns. Virtual patients that encourage thoroughness could help future physicians avoid missed diagnostic opportunities and enhance the delivery of clinical reasoning teaching.

An electron-deficient metallocavitand with an unusual selectivity towards substituted benzene derivatives during co-crystallizations.

Clinical reasoning performance assessment: using situated cognition theory as a conceptual framework

Teaching Students How to Think: A Longitudinal Qualitative Study of Preclerkship Clinical Reasoning Instruction

Evaluating Clinical Reasoning in Undergraduate Medical Education: The Value of a Virtual Oral Assessment

Using Virtual Patients to Explore the Clinical Reasoning Skills of Medical Students: Mixed Methods Study

Increased magnesium intake prevents hyperlipidemia and insulin resistance and reduces lipid peroxidation in fructose-fed rats.

Assessing clinical reasoning in undergraduate medical students during history taking with an empirically derived scale for clinical reasoning indicators

Using an experiential learning model to teach clinical reasoning theory and cognitive bias: an evaluation of a first-year medical student curriculum

Steps to improve the teaching of clinical reasoning in dermatology: A scoping review and proposal

Fetal Isolated Ventriculomegaly: Is There any Neonatal Consequences?

Comparing the understanding of subjects receiving a candidate malaria vaccine in the United States and Mali.

Implementation of three knowledge-oriented instructional strategies to teach clinical reasoning: Self-explanation, a concept mapping exercise, and deliberate reflection: AMEE Guide No. 150

A novel approach to clinical thinking training for medical students: the combined World Café discussion and case-based learning experience introduction

Teaching clinical reasoning: principles from the literature to help improve instruction from the classroom to the bedside

Analysis of major lipid classes and their fatty acids in a cestode parasite of domestic fowl, raillietina (Fuhrmannetta) echinobothrida

Minding the gap: towards a shared clinical reasoning lexicon across the pre-clerkship/clerkship transition

A Pilot Longitudinal Clinical Reasoning Curriculum for Pediatric Residents

Using Group History-Taking and Individual Reasoning to Identify Shortcomings in Clinical Reasoning for Medical Students

Teaching and learning clinical reasoning skill in undergraduate medical students: A scoping review

Distribution of inhibitory synapses on the somata of pyramidal neurons in cat motor cortex.

renal artery stenoses ' ' Apparent ' ' heart failure : a syndrome caused