What Is life? Rethinking Biology in Light of Fundamental Parameters

Jacques Fantini,Mélanie Matveeva,Marine Lefebvre,Henri Chahinian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/life14030280

2024-02-20

Life

Abstract:Defining life is an arduous task that has puzzled philosophers and scientists for centuries. Yet biology suffers from a lack of clear definition, putting biologists in a paradoxical situation where one can describe at the atomic level complex objects that remain globally poorly defined. One could assume that such descriptions make it possible to perfectly characterize living systems. However, many cases of misinterpretation put this assumption into perspective. In this article, we focus on critical parameters such as time, water, entropy, space, quantum properties, and electrostatic potential to redefine the nature of living matter, with special emphasis on biological coding. Where does the DNA double helix come from, why cannot the reproduction of living organisms occur without mutations, what are the limitations of the genetic code, and why do not all proteins have a stable three-dimensional structure? There are so many questions that cannot be resolved without considering the aforementioned parameters. Indeed, (i) time and space constrain many biological mechanisms and impose drastic solutions on living beings (enzymes, transporters); (ii) water controls the fidelity of DNA replication and the structure/disorder balance of proteins; (iii) entropy is the driving force of many enzymatic reactions and molecular interactions; (iv) quantum mechanisms explain why a molecule as simple as hydrocyanic acid (HCN) foreshadows the helical structure of DNA, how DNA is stabilized, why mutations occur, and how the Earth magnetic field can influence the migration of birds; (v) electrostatic potential controls epigenetic mechanisms, lipid raft functions, and virus infections. We consider that raising awareness of these basic parameters is critical for better understanding what life is, and how it handles order and chaos through a combination of genetic and epigenetic mechanisms. Thus, we propose to incorporate these parameters into the definition of life.

biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problem does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to rethink the fundamental definition of life and its biological characteristics. The author points out that defining life is a daunting task that has puzzled philosophers and scientists for centuries. Currently, biology lacks a clear definition of life, leading to confusion among biologists when describing complex atomic-level objects. The paper proposes that some key parameters (such as time, water, entropy, space, quantum mechanisms, and electric potential) need to be considered to redefine the essence of life.

Specifically, the paper attempts to answer the following questions:
1. **The origin of the DNA double helix structure**: How did the DNA double helix structure form?
2. **Mutations in the reproductive process**: Why are mutations inevitable during the reproduction of organisms?
3. **Limitations of the genetic code**: What are the limitations of the genetic code?
4. **Three-dimensional stability of proteins**: Why don't all proteins have stable three-dimensional structures?

The paper argues that these questions can only be answered by considering the aforementioned fundamental parameters and emphasizes that these parameters are crucial for understanding life phenomena. For example:
- **Time**: Many biological mechanisms are influenced by time constraints.
- **Water**: Water controls the fidelity of DNA replication and the balance between protein structure and disorder.
- **Entropy**: Entropy drives many enzymatic reactions and molecular interactions.
- **Quantum mechanisms**: Quantum mechanisms explain how simple molecules (such as hydrogen cyanide) foreshadow the helical structure of DNA, DNA stability, and the occurrence of mutations.
- **Electric potential**: Electric potential controls epigenetic mechanisms, lipid raft functions, and viral infections.

In summary, this paper attempts to redefine the essence of life by integrating these fundamental parameters and to better understand how life manages the relationship between order and chaos through genetic and epigenetic mechanisms.