The Winding Road from Origin to Emergence (of Life)

Wolfgang Nitschke,Orion Farr,Nil Gaudu,Chloé Truong,François Guyot,Michael J. Russell,Simon Duval

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/life14050607

2024-05-10

Life

Abstract:Humanity's strive to understand why and how life appeared on planet Earth dates back to prehistoric times. At the beginning of the 19th century, empirical biology started to tackle this question yielding both Charles Darwin's Theory of Evolution and the paradigm that the crucial trigger putting life on its tracks was the appearance of organic molecules. In parallel to these developments in the biological sciences, physics and physical chemistry saw the fundamental laws of thermodynamics being unraveled. Towards the end of the 19th century and during the first half of the 20th century, the tensions between thermodynamics and the "organic-molecules-paradigm" became increasingly difficult to ignore, culminating in Erwin Schrödinger's 1944 formulation of a thermodynamics-compliant vision of life and, consequently, the prerequisites for its appearance. We will first review the major milestones over the last 200 years in the biological and the physical sciences, relevant to making sense of life and its origins and then discuss the more recent reappraisal of the relative importance of metal ions vs. organic molecules in performing the essential processes of a living cell. Based on this reassessment and the modern understanding of biological free energy conversion (aka bioenergetics), we consider that scenarios wherein life emerges from an abiotic chemiosmotic process are both thermodynamics-compliant and the most parsimonious proposed so far.

biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is the understanding of the origin of life. Specifically, the authors review significant milestones in biology and physics over the past 200 years in understanding the origin of life and reassess the relative importance of metal ions and organic molecules in fundamental cellular processes. Based on the understanding of modern bioenergetic conversion, the authors propose that life may have spontaneously arisen from abiotic chemical osmotic processes, and this scenario is both thermodynamically plausible and currently the most concise explanation.

The core issues of the paper are:
1. **Are organic molecules a necessary condition for the emergence of life**: The traditional view holds that the presence of organic molecules (such as amino acids, nucleobases, lipids, and sugars) is a necessary condition for the emergence of life. However, the authors believe this view has limitations.
2. **The relationship between thermodynamics and the origin of life**: The authors explore the relationship between the laws of thermodynamics (especially the second law) and the origin of life, pointing out that life systems maintain their ordered state by consuming free energy, which is consistent with thermodynamic principles.
3. **Entropy reduction phenomena in abiotic systems**: The authors discuss that local entropy reduction phenomena also exist in abiotic systems, which occur in systems far from thermodynamic equilibrium and can be explained by the flow of free energy.

In summary, this paper attempts to address the problem of how to reinterpret the origin of life from the perspectives of thermodynamics and abiotic chemistry, challenging the traditional organic molecule-centered view and proposing a new model of the origin of life that is more consistent with scientific principles.