Abstract:Background: The accuracy of clinical laboratory results is paramount for effective patient diagnosis and treatment. However, errors in the pre-analytical phase, particularly during phlebotomy, significantly impact the reliability of laboratory data. With the Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute (CLSI) guidelines serving as a benchmark for best practices in blood collection, adherence to these standards is crucial for minimizing errors. Objective: This study aimed to assess compliance with modified CLSI guidelines in phlebotomy procedures within a healthcare setting and identify the most prevalent errors in the pre-analytical phase that could compromise patient safety and the integrity of laboratory results. Methods: Conducted at the Combined Military Hospital Lahore from January to March 2023, this observational study scrutinized phlebotomy practices across three distinct healthcare settings: emergency department, outpatient department, and clinical wards. A structured checklist, adapted from the European Federation for Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine (EFLM) guidelines and aligned with local modifications, was employed to evaluate compliance in 20 specific areas of phlebotomy practice. A total of 285 phlebotomies were observed by specialized staff, with data analyzed using SPSS version 25 to compare error frequencies and compliance rates across different settings and among various healthcare professionals. Results: The study revealed an overall compliance rate of 88% for identified request forms, 76% for patient identification according to local guidelines, and 66% for proper hand sanitization. However, significant errors were identified in checking for potential complications of venipuncture (34% compliance), with tubes being clearly under or overfilled (46% compliance), and in verifying that patients were prepared for phlebotomy (46% compliance). The error frequency varied across settings, with the highest discrepancies observed in the emergency department. Differences in compliance rates between laboratory staff and nurses were statistically significant in key areas, including patient identification (p<0.001) and tube labeling (p=0.081). Conclusion: The study highlights a critical need for improving adherence to CLSI guidelines within phlebotomy practices to enhance patient safety and the accuracy of laboratory results. Targeted educational and training interventions are essential for addressing the identified gaps in compliance, particularly in patient identification, sample volume control, and verification of patient preparation for phlebotomy.

Simple signature/countersignature shared-accountability quality improvement initiative to improve reliability of blood sample collection: an essential clinical task

Practice of information management of the whole process of blood sampling in emergency department

Improving adherence to facility protocol and reducing blood culture contamination in an intensive care unit: A quality improvement project

An emergency department intervention to improve earlier detection of community-onset bloodstream infection among hospitalized patients

Improving communication of critical test results in a pediatric academic setting: key lessons in achieving and sustaining positive outcomes

Quality Improvement in the Coagulation Laboratory: Reducing the Number of Insufficient Blood Draw Specimens for Coagulation Testing

Improving Patient Experience of Wait Times and Courtesy Through Electronic Sign-in and Notification in the Phlebotomy Clinic

Increased Patient Satisfaction and a Reduction in Pre-Analytical Errors Following Implementation of an Electronic Specimen Collection Module in Outpatient Phlebotomy

Using lean management to reduce blood culture contamination

Patient safety in actioning and communicating blood test results in primary care: a UK wide audit using the Primary care Academic CollaboraTive (PACT)

Quality improvement project: Reducing non-conformities of the samples for haemostasis testing in a secondary healthcare centre through the nurses' education in phlebotomy

Routine Infectious Diseases Consultations on a Pediatric Cardiac Unit to Improve Positive Blood Culture Management

Blood self-sampling devices: innovation, interpretation and implementation in total lab automation

Transfusion sample mislabelling and wrong blood in tube in the UK: Insights from the national comparative audits of blood transfusion in 2012 and 2022

Reducing turnaround time for routine outpatient biochemical tests through Lean Six Sigma: A case study in China

Performance evaluation of the introduction of full sample traceability system within the specimen collection process

A hospital-wide quality-improvement collaborative to reduce catheter-associated bloodstream infections

ISO 9001:2015 Internal Audits for Financial and Strategic Decisions in Reducing Blood Culture Contamination

Observational Study on Adherence to modified Clinical and Laboratory Standard Institute H3-A6 Guidelines on Blood Sampling Procedures

Applying sigma metrics to assess quality control processes in the transfusion transmissible infection screening laboratory of a blood center

[Reducing Blood Culture Contamination Rates in the Emergency Department]