Abstract:Two flaws in concepts were identified and discussed in the paper ("Removal of Pb(II) from contaminated waters using cellulose sulfate/chitosan aerogel: Equilibrium, kinetics, and thermodynamic studies". J. Environ. Manag. 286, 112167; https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2021.112167). In the literature, the Radke-Prausnitz model is expressed in different forms, but some of them are incorrect. The first flaw is related to the nonlinear form of the Radke-Prausnitz model. The nonlinear form of this three parameters model is expressed correctly as [Formula: see text] . The units of two parameters are ARP (L/kg) and BRP [(mol/kg)/(mol/L)β] by considering qe (mol/kg) and Ce (mol/L). The limitation for its exponent is 0≤ β ≤ 1. This model is developed by two authors (Radke and Prausnitz). The correct paper (DOI: 10.1021/i160044a003) cited as reference of this model is "Radke, C.J., Prausnitz, J.M., 1972. Adsorption of organic solutes from dilute aqueous solution of activated carbon. Ind. Eng. Chem. 11, 445-451". The second is the misconception about the unit of the Langmuir constant (KL; L/mg). The correct unit of KL is litre per milligram of adsorbate (i.e., Pb ions), not litre per milligram of adsorbent (the cellulose sulfate/chitosan aerogel material as reported by Najaflou and co-workers. They proposed a new equation [KL (L/mg) × m/V (mg/L)] to convert the Langmuir constant and then applied it to calculate the thermodynamic parameters of the adsorption process. The m/V is a solid/liquid ratio (g/L or kg/L). However, this conversion and application are mistakes that were thoroughly discussed in this paper. The correction is KEqo=1γAdsorbate×KLLmol×ComolL, with C° (1 mol/L by definition) being the standard state of solute and γAdsorbate (dimensionless) being the activity coefficient of adsorbate in solution. To avoid unexpected mistakes, the present authors suggest that researchers should have a correct citation (citing the original reference instead of using secondary references) and check the consistency of units (i.e., the constants of adsorption models) carefully.

Comment on the calculation of equilibrium constant and thermodynamic parameters by the distribution coefficient in Environmental Research 203 (2022) 111814

Erratum: Central mean temperature scaling in compressible turbulent channel flows with symmetric isothermal boundaries [Phys. Rev. Fluids <b>7</b> , 044606 (2022)]

Comments on the calculation of the standard equilibrium constant using the Langmuir model in Journal of Hazardous Materials 422 (2022) 126863

Reasonable calculation of the thermodynamic parameters from adsorption equilibrium constant

Comments on “Corrigendum to ‘Thermodynamic solubility of tetraethyl ranelate in ten organic solvents at different temperatures. [J. Mol. Liq. 216 (2016) 771–780]’”

How to avoid mistakes in treating adsorption isotherm data (liquid and solid phases): Some comments about correctly using Radke-Prausnitz nonlinear model and Langmuir equilibrium constant

Comments on Thermodiffusion: The physico-chemical mechanics view. J. Chem. Phys. 154, 024112 (2021)

Linking Thermal Conductivity to Equations of State Using the Residual Entropy Scaling Theory

Correction to the thermodynamic calculation using the Langmuir isotherm model by Saeed et al. (2022)

Reply to “Comments regarding ‘Solubility determination and crystallization thermodynamics of an intermediate in different organic solvents’”

Correction: Toikka et al. Some Remarks on the Boundary of Thermodynamic Stability. Entropy 2023, 25, 969

Reply to “Comments regarding ‘Solid-liquid equilibrium solubility, thermodynamic properties and solvent effect of 3,4-dinitro-1H-pyrazole in different pure solvents’”

Comment on "Numerical study with OpenFOAM on heat conduction problems in heterogeneous media" by K. Zhang, C.-A. Wang, J.-Y. Tan, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, Vol. 124 (2018) 1156–1162

Comment to the article "A crucial incorrect understanding in the traditional solution theory" from Zhong-Hua Yang and Kun-Peng Yang (J. Molecular Liq. 310 (2020) 112379)

Comments on: Generalization of thermodynamics in of fractional-order derivatives and calculation of heat-transfer properties of noble gases, Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry (2018) 133:1189–1194

Corrigendum on “experimental study and thermodynamic modeling of a novel heat resistant explosive in different mono solvents”

Thermodynamic Equilibrium in Open Chemical Systems

Revisiting the calculation of thermodynamic parameters of adsorption processes from the modified equilibrium constant of the Redlich–Peterson model

Erratum: “Thermodynamic effects at Venturi cavitation in different liquids” [Phys. Fluids <b>34</b>, 083310 (2022)]

Introducing Quantitative Assessment of Accuracy for the Equilibrium Constant of Affinity Complexes

Some comments on `Equation for the second virial coefficient`