Abstract:Consent in medical practice is a process riddled with layers of complexities. To some extent, this is inevitable given that different medical conditions raise different sets of issues for doctors and patients. Informed consent and risk assessment are highly significant public health issues that have become even more prominent during the course of the Covid-19 pandemic. In this article we identity relevant factors for clinicians to consider when ensuring consent for solid organ transplantation. Consent to undergo solid organ transplantation is more complex than most surgical and other clinical interventions because of the many factors involved, the complexity of the options and the need to balance competing risks. We first out the context in which consent is given by the patient. We then outline the legal principles pertaining to consent in medical practice as it applies in the UK and the implication of recent legal judgments. The third section highlights specific complexities of consent in organ transplantation and identifies relevant factors in determining consent for organ transplantation. The fourth section offers practical recommendations. We propose a novel 'multi-factor approach' to informed consent in transplantation which includes understanding risk, effective communication, and robust review processes. Whilst understanding risk and communication are a given, our suggestion is that including review processes into the consent process is essential. By this we specifically mean identifying and creating room for discretion in decision-making to better ensure that informed consent is given in practice. Discretion implies that health care professionals use their judgement to use the legal judgements as guidance rather than prescriptive. Discretion is further defined by identifying the relevant options and scope of clinical and personal factors in specified transplantation decisions. In particular, we also highlight the need to pay attention to the institutional dimension in the consent process. To that end, our recommendations identify a gap in the current approaches to consent. The identification of areas of discretion in decision-making processes is essential for determining when patients need to be involved. In other words, clinicians and healthcare professionals need to consider carefully when there is room for direction and where there is little or no room for exercising discretion. In sum, our proposed approach is a modest contribution to the on-going debate about consent in medicine.

Applying utilitarianism to the presumed consent system for organ donation to consider the moral pros and cons

Why did England change its law on deceased organ donation in 2019? The dynamic interplay between evidence and values

Ethical, Psychological and Social Un/certainties in the Face of Deemed Consent for Organ Donation in England

Tumor necrosis factor-alpha is persistently expressed in cardiac allografts in the absence of histological or clinical evidence of rejection.

Trends in organ donation in England, Scotland and Wales in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic and 'opt-out' legislation

Opt-out Scheme is Still Best Way to Increase Organ Donation, Says BMA.

Ethical and legal issues associated with organ donation and transplantation

Differential impact of opt-in, opt-out policies on deceased organ donation rates: a mixed conceptual and empirical study

Premortem interventions in dying children to optimise organ donation: an ethical analysis

Consent in organ transplantation: putting legal obligations and guidelines into practice

Current Status of Organ Donation

Does implementing opt-out solve the organ shortage problem? Evidence from a synthetic control approach

Deemed consent for deceased organ donation

Individual and Family Decisions About Organ Donation

Does It Matter How We Die? Ethical and Legal Issues Raised by Combining Euthanasia and Organ Transplantation

Who Are the Donors in Organ Donation? The Family's Perspective in Mandated Choice

Problematising the ethics of organ donation after circulatory death in the UK

[Anastomotic false-diverticulum causing an atypical dumping syndrome. A case report].

What determinants impact deceased organ donation consent in the adult intensive care unit? An integrative review exploring the perspectives of staff and families

A Multiethnic Asian Perspective of Presumed Consent for Organ Donation: A Population-Based Perception Study

When is directed deceased donation justified? Practical, ethical, and legal issues