Ethical and legal issues associated with organ donation and transplantation

Jennifer Lewis,Dale Gardiner

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mpsur.2023.06.010

2023-07-01

Surgery (Oxford)

Abstract:Organ donation and transplantation has transformed the lives of many around the world. Despite its place as a treatment option for numerous forms of end-stage organ disease, the need for careful ethical and legal consideration is paramount. In this article we discuss three rules: the Dead Donor Rule, which underpins the use of organs for donation from deceased individuals; the ‘Rule of Consent’ which includes consideration of both deceased and living donors and the recipients of organs; and finally the ‘Fair Transplant Rule’, which offers protection from the challenging issues of exploitation and organ allocation fairness. When applied in combination these rules should provide an ethically robust platform on which to deliver organ donation and transplantation. These rules can act universally and are applicable across all jurisdictions. Clinicians are encouraged to see organ donation not as a single event, but as a complex combination of individual ethical and legal activities which require independent consideration specific to the donor patient.

English Else