Abstract:Reports of not feeling understood are frequent in testimonies of psychological trauma. I argue that these feelings are not a matter of a cognitive failure but rather an expression of the absence of a more pervasive background feeling of belonging. Contemporary accounts of we-intentionality promise but ultimately fall short in explaining this sense of belonging. Gerda Walther offers an alternative account of communal experiences. Her notion of "habitual unification" can explain the background feelings of belonging that are woven through the individual's everyday experience of being in a shared world. Having unified with another person, the world feels different. It is now experienced in light of a "we." This is not only the case in actual, singular person-to-person encounters. Unification with others becomes habitual: it retreats into the background of the individual's awareness, colouring their experience of the world. Thus sedimented, it forms a background sense of belonging to a shared world. Unification is enabled by experiencing others as being similar in a significant way, such as having the same experiences, values, or basic attitude: in Walther's words, as being a "human, who also…." This, I shall argue, is impacted through traumatizing experiences. Trauma survivors struggle to experience others as "humans, who also…," resulting in a failure of unification and thus impeding feelings of belonging. Trauma testimonies also suggest that actively seeking out recognition of similarities and shared aspects of experience may once again enable experiencing others as "humans, who also…," thus enabling unification and re-establishing a sense of belonging.

Belonging on the Edge

Belonging and Its Discontents

Affiliation vs. Alienation

Embracing Complexity and the Need for Inclusive Belongings

Belonging or Opposing? A Grounded Theory Approach to Young People's Cultural Identity in a Majority/Minority Societal Context

Beyond Discontent: Dialogues on Subjectivity and Belonging

Unhinged: A Prospective Perspective on Being Unsafe1

The Need to Belong: a Deep Dive into the Origins, Implications, and Future of a Foundational Construct

Belonging as situated practice

Does one truly need to belong?: A case for the need to meaningfully exist

Splitting, Confusion, and Hope

Background Feelings of Belonging and Psychological Trauma

The narcissism of minor resemblances: searching for allies at times of threat

Developing the Concept of Belonging Work for Social Research

The Deep Psychology of Eudaimonia and Virtue: Belonging, Loyalty and the Anterior Cingulate Cortex

The Essence That Is Belonging Together: Identity, Embodiment, and Skillful Coping During the 2015 Greek Referendum

Transgenerational Transmission of Privilege and Trauma: Locating Jewish Experience in Racial Reckoning within Psychoanalysis

Afraid to Commit: Proposing Psychoanalysis and the Paradox of the Analyst's Desire

On Being Accepted: Interrogating How University Cultural Scripts Shape Personal and Political Facets of Belonging

Awakening to Our Implicated Selves: Paralysis, Disorientation and What's at Stake Psychically