Abstract:The growing implementation of digital education comes with an increased need to understand the impact of digital tools on learning. Previous behavioral studies have shown that handwriting on paper is more effective for learning than typing on a keyboard. However, the impact of writing with a digital pen on a tablet remains to be clarified. In the present study, we compared learning by handwriting with an ink pen on paper, handwriting with a digital pen on a tablet, and typing on a keyboard. Behavioral and electroencephalographic indices were measured immediately after learning with each writing tool. The moods of the subjects during the training were also assessed. The participants were divided according to their use of digital pen in their everyday lives, allowing us to take into account the effect of the familiarity with the digital pen on the learning process (familiar group vs. unfamiliar group). We performed an EEG experiment applying a repetition priming paradigm. In each trial, a learned foreign language word (prime word) and a mother tongue word (target word) were consecutively presented. The target word was either semantically identical to the prime word (repetitive condition) or different (non-repetitive condition). We assumed that a larger priming effect on N400 reflects larger learning progress. The familiar group showed a greater N400 priming effect for words learned with the digital or ink pen than those learned with the keyboard. The unfamiliar group showed the greater N400 priming effect for words learned with the ink pen compared with words learned by typing. In addition, positive mood during learning was significantly higher during handwriting than during typing, regardless of the groups. On the other hand, the behavioral indices were not influenced by the writing tool. These results suggest that the movements involved in handwriting allow a greater memorization of new words. The advantage of handwriting over typing might also be caused by a more positive mood during learning. Finally, our results show that handwriting with a digital pen and tablet can increase the ability to learn compared with keyboard typing once the individuals are accustomed to it.

Comparing factual recall of tapped vs. handwritten text

Mobile-assisted or paper-based? The influence of the reading medium on the reading comprehension of English as a foreign language

The Value of Handwritten Notes: A Failure to Find State-Dependent Effects When Using a Laptop to Take Notes and Complete a Quiz

Advantage of Handwriting Over Typing on Learning Words: Evidence From an N400 Event-Related Potential Index

Differences in autobiographical memories reported using text and voice during everyday life

Unveiling Neurocognitive Disparities in Encoding and Retrieval between Paper and Digital Tablet-Based Learning

Effectiveness of Digital Note-Taking on Students’ Performance in Declarative, Procedural and Conditional Knowledge Learning

Effects of Dictation, Speech to Text, and Handwriting on the Written Composition of Elementary School English Language Learners

A Need-finding Study for Understanding Text Entry in Smartphone App Usage

Investigation of a Chinese character writing app: Learners’ perspectives

Older Adults' Text Entry on Smartphones and Tablets: Investigating Effects of Display Size and Input Method on Acceptance and Performance

Distinctions Between Mobile-Assisted and Paper-Based EFL Reading Comprehension Performance: Reading Cognitive Load As a Mediator

Typed Versus Handwritten Lecture Notes and College Student Achievement: A Meta-Analysis

Handwriting versus keyboarding: Does writing modality affect quality of narratives written by beginning writers?

Second language reading and recall processes under different reading purposes: an eye-tracking, keystroke-logging, and stimulated recall study

Note‐taking by university students on paper or a computer: Strategies during initial note‐taking and revision

Note-taking fosters distance video learning: smartphones as risk and intellectual values as protective factors

Self-directed learning of core vocabulary in English by EFL learners: comparing the outcomes from paper and mobile application flashcards

The role of cognitive individual differences in digital versus pen-and-paper writing

Can touchscreens replace teachers? Chinese children's character learning from a touchscreen-based app, video, or face-to-face instruction

Handwriting but not typewriting leads to widespread brain connectivity: a high-density EEG study with implications for the classroom