Abstract:The ability to perform revisions targeting the content of the text is important for text quality improvement, and it is hypothesized that lower-level transcription processes need to be automatized in order to free up capacity for higher-level processes such as revision. However, for people with reading and writing difficulties due to underlying difficulties with decoding and spelling, the transcription process is rarely automatized because of their troubles with spelling. One possible way to circumvent spelling difficulties, and possibly gaining capacity for higher level processes such as revision, is to write using speech-to-text (STT). This study investigates the revisions performed when children with reading and writing difficulties ( n = 16), and a reference group without such difficulties ( n = 12), compose text using STT and using a keyboard. More specifically, the study investigates whether, and if so how, revisions at various levels, errors left in the final text product, and text quality differ between conditions and between groups. The compositions were logged using keystroke logging (keyboard) and audio- and screen-recording (STT). The level of revisions were manually coded. The results showed that children with reading and writing difficulties gain more from composing with STT compared to keyboard than the reference group. They leave fewer errors in their final text product when composing by means of STT, even though they need to engage more in the correction of surface errors because of the large number of STT errors. Despite the numerous STT errors, neither the proportion of meaning-related revisions nor text quality decreased in composing with STT (for either of the groups). Taken together, the results suggest, albeit not emphatically, that STT may be appropriate as a facilitatory tool for children with reading and writing difficulties. However, more research is needed to investigate instruction that addresses strategies for STT transcription and highlights the shortcomings of the tool in the target language, and also focuses specifically on higher-level aspects of composition such as planning or revising, in order to gain further knowledge about the feasibility of using STT as a means of composition for children who struggle with writing, and its possible effects over time.

Effects of Dictation, Speech to Text, and Handwriting on the Written Composition of Elementary School English Language Learners

Comparative Study about the Impacts of Chinese Automated Writing Evaluation (AWE) Feedback and Teacher Feedback on Middle School Students’ Writing Practice

Revisions in written composition: Introducing speech-to-text to children with reading and writing difficulties

Handwriting versus keyboarding: Does writing modality affect quality of narratives written by beginning writers?

The contributions of executive functioning to handwritten and keyboarded compositions in Year 2 children

The Impact of Orthography on Text Production in Three Languages: Catalan, English, and Spanish

The Influence of Cross-Linguistic Similarity and Language Background on Writing to Dictation

The effect of written text on comprehension of spoken English as a foreign language

Changes in DTI Diffusivity and fMRI Connectivity Cluster Coefficients for Students with and without Specific Learning Disabilities In Written Language: Brain's Response to Writing Instruction

Computerized Writing and Reading Instruction for Students in Grades 4 to 9 With Specific Learning Disabilities Affecting Written Language

Handwriting fluency and the quality of primary grade students’ writing

Online management of text production from pictures: a comparison between fifth graders and undergraduate students

Typing Versus Handwriting: A Preliminary Investigation of Modality Effects in the Writing Output of People With Aphasia

The Effects of Oral Discussion and Text Chat on L2 Chinese Writing

Strategies for Teaching English in a Computer-Assisted Writing Learning Model

The role of cognitive individual differences in digital versus pen-and-paper writing

The Influence of Texting Language on Grammar and Executive Functions in Primary School Children

Speech-to-text intervention to support text production for students with intellectual disabilities

Writing Instruction Improves Students' Writing Skills Differentially Depending on Focal Instruction and Children: A Meta-Analysis for Primary Grade Students

Comparing monomodal traditional writing and digital multimodal composing in EAP classrooms: Linguistic performance and writing development

Scoring and Consequential Validity Evidence of Computer- and Paper-Based Writing Tests in Times of Change