Glottal Imaging Study Comparing Vowel Phonation with Semioccluded Vocal Tract Exercises (SOVTEs) Produced Loudly
Anne-Maria Laukkanen,Vojtěch Radolf,Vítězslav Bula,Jaromír Horáček,Ahmed Geneid
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvoice.2024.06.019
IF: 2.3
2024-07-14
Journal of Voice
Abstract:Summary Objectives This study aimed to estimate vocal loading in loud phonation of a vowel and two widely used semiocclusion voice exercises (SOVTEs). Impact stress ( IS ) was estimated from glottal closing speed, inertial forces from the second derivative of glottal opening and closing. Study design Experimental study in vivo . Methods A vocally healthy male sustained the [o:] vowel with habitual loudness and loudly: (1) without a tube, (2) into a silicone "Lax Vox" type tube (35 cm in length, 10 mm in diameter) outer end submerged 10 cm in water, and (3) into a straw (length 12.6 cm, diameter 2.5 mm) the outer end in air. He tried to use equal effort in all loud samples. High-speed video-laryngo-endoscopy was performed with a rigid scope. Oral air pressure (P oral ) was registered in a mouthpiece through which the endoscope was inserted into the larynx and to which the tubes were attached air-tightly. Results Compared with vowel phonation at habitual loudness , mean of maximal glottal width (max GW) increased by 44.1% for loud tube phonation and decreased by 1.8% for loud straw phonation, and mean absolute value of minimum GW time derivative d min increased by 57.1% for tube and by 29.5% for straw suggesting faster glottal closing. Compared with loud vowel phonation , max GW increased by 22.6% for loud tube phonation, while it decreased by 16.6% for loud straw phonation. For the tube, d min de creased by 7.6% and for the straw by 23.8%. Maximal acceleration (ACC) and deceleration (DC) values were larger for the tube and smaller for the straw than the values for both vowel phonations. Conclusions IS , deduced from d min , increased in loud SOVTEs compared to vowel phonation at a conversational loudness, but remained lower in loud SOVTEs than in loud vowel phonation, particularly with a narrow straw, which also reduced inertial forces, as suggested by the reduced ACC and DC.
otorhinolaryngology,audiology & speech-language pathology