Comparison of Sensor-Based and Audible Detection of Milking Liner Slips during Machine Milking of Dairy Cows

Matthias Wieland,Madeleine Eve Spellman,Kerry Lynn Case,Christina Marie Geary,Anja Sipka
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/s24051361
IF: 3.9
2024-02-20
Sensors
Abstract:On-farm milk flow meter technology facilitates real-time assessment of individual cow milking observations and could be used to detect milking liner slips during machine milking of dairy cows. Here, we compared the accuracy of on-farm milk flow meters for detecting milking liner slips with that of audible detection and that of a portable vacuum recording system. Compared to audible detection methods, the on-farm milk flow meter facilitated the detection of milking liner slips with moderate accuracy. Using the vacuum recording system as the gold standard, the milk flow meter system failed to detect most of the liner slips, leading to poor agreement between the two devices. We conclude that the on-farm milk flow meter system tested here compared well with audible detection; however, when vacuum recordings were considered, we found significant levels of under-detection. Taken together, dairy operators may use the on-farm milk flow meter system to inform adjustments of the milking machine settings and monitor milking routine performance. However, the system is not suitable for monitoring short-duration vacuum fluctuations. Future research is warranted to optimize the sensor-based detection of milking liner slips.
engineering, electrical & electronic,chemistry, analytical,instruments & instrumentation
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main aim of this paper is to evaluate the accuracy of electronic milk flow meters used on farms in detecting milking liner slips during the machine milking process of cows, and to compare these results with traditional auditory detection methods and a portable vacuum recording system. Specifically, the study is divided into two parts: 1. **Part 1 (Experiment 1)**: Three observers performed auditory detection at different stages of the milking process to identify milking liner slips, and these data were compared with those from the electronic milk flow meter. The study found that, compared to auditory detection, the electronic milk flow meter could detect milking liner slips with moderate accuracy. However, the flow meter system failed to detect most short-term vacuum fluctuations. 2. **Part 2 (Experiment 2)**: Using a portable vacuum recording system as the "gold standard," the performance of the electronic milk flow meter was further evaluated. The results showed that, when compared to the vacuum recording system, the electronic milk flow meter significantly underestimated the occurrence rate of milking liner slips. In summary, the authors concluded that although the electronic milk flow meter system can be used to adjust milking machine settings and monitor the performance of the milking process, it is not suitable for monitoring short-term vacuum fluctuations. Future research needs to further optimize sensor-based milking liner slip detection technology.