Abstract:The detection of causal effects among simultaneous observations provides knowledge about the underlying network, and is a topic of interests in many scientific areas. Over the years different causality measures have been developed, each with their own advantages and disadvantages. However, an extensive evaluation study is missing. In this work we consider some of the best-known causality measures i.e., cross-correlation, (conditional) Granger causality index (CGCI), partial directed coherence (PDC), directed transfer function (DTF), and partial mutual information on mixed embedding (PMIME). To correct for noise-related spurious connections, each measure (except PMIME) is tested for statistical significance based on surrogate data. The performance of the causality metrics is evaluated on a set of simulation models with distinct characteristics, to assess how well they work in- as well as outside of their "comfort zone." PDC and DTF perform best on systems with frequency-specific connections, while PMIME is the only one able to detect non-linear interactions. The varying performance depending on the system characteristics warrants the use of multiple measures and comparing their results to avoid errors. Furthermore, lags between coupled variables are inherent to real-world systems and could hold essential information on the network dynamics. They are however often not taken into account and we lack proper tools to estimate them. We propose three new methods for lag estimation in multivariate time series, based on autoregressive modelling and information theory. One of the autoregressive methods and the one based on information theory were able to reliably identify the correct lag value in different simulated systems. However, only the latter was able to maintain its performance in the case of non-linear interactions. As a clinical application, the same methods are also applied on an intracranial recording of an epileptic seizure. The combined knowledge from the causality measures and insights from the simulations, on how these measures perform under different circumstances and when to use which one, allow us to recreate a plausible network of the seizure propagation that supports previous observations of desynchronisation and synchronisation during seizure progression. The lag estimation results show absence of a relationship between connectivity strength and estimated lag values, which contradicts the line of thinking in connectivity shaped by the neuron doctrine.

Benchmarking nonparametric Granger causality: Robustness against downsampling and influence of spectral decomposition parameters

A Method to Study Global Spatial Patterns Related to Sensory Perception in Scalp EEG.

Causality analysis of neural connectivity: critical examination of existing methods and advances of new methods.

Directed neural interactions in fMRI: a comparison between Granger Causality and Effective Connectivity

Nonparametric Dynamic Granger Causality based on Multi-Space Spectrum Fusion for Time-varying Directed Brain Network Construction

Detectability of Granger causality for subsampled continuous-time neurophysiological processes

Effective Connectivity Estimation by a Hybrid Neural Network, Empirical Wavelet Transform, and Bayesian Optimization

Multiscale Bayesian State Space Model for Granger Causality Analysis of Brain Signal

Is Granger Causality a Viable Technique for Analyzing fMRI Data?

Identifying oscillatory brain networks with hidden Gaussian graphical spectral models of MEEG

On the self-similar asymptotics for generalized non-linear kinetic Maxwell models

Identification of oscillatory brain networks with Hidden Gaussian Graphical Spectral models of EEG/MEG

Constructing Time-Varying Directed EEG Network by Multivariate Nonparametric Dynamical Granger Causality

Brain Waves Analysis Via a Non-Parametric Bayesian Mixture of Autoregressive Kernels

Kernel Granger Causality Based on Back Propagation Neural Network Fuzzy Inference System on fMRI Data

Evaluation of Directed Causality Measures and Lag Estimations in Multivariate Time-Series

An information-theoretic framework for conditional causality analysis of brain networks

Modeling Brain Connectivity with Graphical Models on Frequency Domain

Detecting connectivity in EEG: A comparative study of data-driven effective connectivity measures

An efficient approach to characterize spatio-temporal dependence in cortical surface fMRI data

Minimum-phase property of the hemodynamic response function, and implications for Granger Causality in fMRI