Abstract:Inferring and understanding the underlying connectivity structure of a system solely from the observed activity of its constituent components is a challenge in many areas of science. In neuroscience, techniques for estimating connectivity are paramount when attempting to understand the network structure of neural systems from their recorded activity patterns. To date, no universally accepted method exists for the inference of effective connectivity, which describes how the activity of a neural node mechanistically affects the activity of other nodes. Here, focussing on purely excitatory networks of small to intermediate size and continuous node dynamics, we provide a systematic comparison of different approaches for estimating effective connectivity. Starting with the Hopf neuron model in conjunction with known ground truth structural connectivity, we reconstruct the system's connectivity matrix using a variety of algorithms. We show that, in sparse non-linear networks with delays, combining a lagged-cross-correlation (LCC) approach with a recently published derivative-based covariance analysis method provides the most reliable estimation of the known ground truth connectivity matrix. We also show that in linear networks, LCC has comparable performance to a method based on transfer entropy, at a drastically lower computational cost. We highlight that LCC works best for small sparse networks, and show how performance decreases in larger and less sparse networks. Applying the method to linear dynamics without time delays, we find that it does not outperform derivative-based methods. Employing the Hopf model, we then use the estimated structural connectivity matrix as the basis for a forward simulation of the system dynamics, in order to recreate the observed node activity patterns. We show that, under certain conditions, the best method, LCC, results in higher trace-to-trace correlations than derivative-based methods for sparse noise-driven systems. Finally, we apply the LCC method to empirical biological data. We reconstruct the structural connectivity of a subset of the nervous system of the nematode C. Elegans. We show that the computationally simple LCC method performs better than another recently published, computationally more expensive reservoir computing-based method. Our results show that a comparatively simple method can be used to reliably estimate directed effective connectivity in sparse neural systems in the presence of spatio-temporal delays and noise. We provide concrete suggestions for the estimation of effective connectivity in a scenario common in biological research, where only neuronal activity of a small set of neurons is known.

Formation of 3-halobenzyne: solvent effects and cycloaddition adducts.

A Deconvolution-Based Approach to Identifying Large-Scale Effective Connectivity.

A Probabilistic Model of Functional Brain Connectivity Network for Discovering Novel Biomarkers.

Nonlinear effective connectivity measure based on adaptive Neuro Fuzzy Inference System and Granger Causality

Perturbing a Neural Network to Infer Effective Connectivity: Evidence from Synthetic EEG Data

A Novel Hybrid Model for Brain Functional Connectivity Based on EEG

Estimating effective connectivity in linear brain network models

Effective Connectivity-Based Neural Decoding: A Causal Interaction-Driven Approach

A nonstationary nonparametric Bayesian approach to dynamically modeling effective connectivity in functional magnetic resonance imaging experiments

Estimating effective connectivity in neural networks: comparison of derivative-based and correlation-based methods

Online Estimating Pairwise Neuronal Functional Connectivity in Brain-Machine Interface

Revealing brain connectivity: graph embeddings for EEG representation learning and comparative analysis of structural and functional connectivity

A Structure-Guided Effective and Temporal-Lag Connectivity Network for Revealing Brain Disorder Mechanisms

Bayesian modelling of effective and functional brain connectivity using hierarchical vector autoregressions

Effective hyper-connectivity network construction and learning: Application to major depressive disorder identification

Focal axonal injury: the early axonal response to stretch

Fetal and neonatal hemopoietic stem cells: considerations in transplantation.

Improved ADHD Diagnosis Using EEG Connectivity and Deep Learning through Combining Pearson Correlation Coefficient and Phase-Locking Value

Spatial-Temporal DAG Convolutional Networks for End-to-End Joint Effective Connectivity Learning and Resting-State fMRI Classification

Identifying effective connectivity parameters in simulated fMRI: a direct comparison of switching linear dynamic system, stochastic dynamic causal, and multivariate autoregressive models

A Constrained, Weighted-L1 Minimization Approach for Joint Discovery of Heterogeneous Neural Connectivity Graphs