The metacognitive abilities of narcissists: Individual differences between grandiose and vulnerable subtypes

Shane Littrell,Jonathan A. Fugelsang,Evan F. Risko

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.paid.2024.112570

IF: 3.95

2024-01-29

Personality and Individual Differences

Abstract:Understanding individual differences in metacognitive ability is vital to gaining a better understanding of how we think about our own thinking. Past research has shown that individual differences in grandiose and vulnerable narcissism are related to overconfidence and self-reported metacognitive insight. Building off this work, we present results from an online study of 208 adults (recruited from the U.S. and Canada) examining the relations of trait grandiose and vulnerable narcissism with metacognitive variables related to memory and intelligence. Results indicate that while grandiose and vulnerable narcissism are similarly related to performance on tasks measuring recall, verbal intelligence, and numeracy, only grandiose narcissism was significantly related to metacognitive performance. Specifically, trait grandiose narcissism was positively associated with overconfidence (bias) for performance on memory and verbal intelligence tasks and negatively associated with the ability to discern correct from incorrect responses on the verbal intelligence task (i.e., discrimination index). Our findings suggest that the two types of narcissism differ not only dispositionally but metacognitively in important ways and provide a deeper understanding of the extent to which individual differences in personality attributes may be related to metacognitive abilities.

psychology, social