Abstract:The central problem of the article is the paradox in the history of Newton’s mechanics: prominent researchers of the genesis of the Principia did not believe Newton’s words about the origin of the idea of universal gravity. They did not believe that he could have come up with this idea as early as 1666, considering circular orbits, and believed that Newton invented the story of the falling apple. The article proposes a “subjunctive” scenario leading to the law of universal gravity and feasible at the level of Galileo’s knowledge and skills in 1611. The basis for such a scenario is the description of a thought experiment in Newton’s manuscript “The System of the World”, preceding the creation of Principia. The proposed reconstruction helps to consider and clarify the concept of “modern physics”, the birth of which was the main event of the Scientific Revolution of the XVI–XVII centuries. The traditional understanding reduces the essence of modern physics to a reliance on experience and on the language of mathematics. Such a definition, however, is not sufficient. The geometry of Euclid and the physics of Archimedes were mathematically perfect, and their axioms were based on objective experience. Despite the importance of the tools of mathematics and experiment, the key innovation of modern physics has become the belief in the hidden fundamental laws of the Universe and in the right of the researcher to invent invisible, “illogical”, “absurd” concepts and postulates, experimentally verifiable only together with the theory based on them. This postulate of fundamental cognitive optimism combines bold ingenuity with a humble need for empirical verification.

Galileo's Double Star: The Experiment That "Proved" the Earth Did Not Move

Learning from the Starry Message: Using Galileo's Sidereus Nuncius in Introductory Astronomy Classes

Galileo’s law of free fall and modern science

Was Galileo Right and the Catholic Church Wrong?

Revisiting the mathematical synthesis of the laws of Kepler and Galileo leading to Newton's law of universal gravitation

Galileo knowledge of optics and the functioning of the telescope revised

Venus's Phases: Evidence Supporting Heliocentrism

Motion of the heavens: a pedagogical proposal for secondary education teachers

126 Arguments Concerning the Motion of the Earth, as presented by Giovanni Battista Riccioli in his 1651 Almagestum Novum

The Naked Eye Stars as Data Supporting Galileo's Copernican Views

MATHEMATICS, THE "BOOK OF NATURE" AND THEOLOGY - GALILEO GALILEI AND THE FOUNDATIONS OF MODERN SCIENCE

History of Scientists? Elimination of Naive Beliefs about Movement - The testing of the theories of Galileo in his lifetime on board of a galley -

Could Galileo Discover the Law of Universal Gravitation in 1611, Was There Newton’s Apple and What Is “Modern Physics”?.

Celestial mechanics, from high-school to Newton's Principia

Orbital motions of astronomical bodies and their Centre of Mass from different reference frames: a conceptual step between the Geocentric and Heliocentric models

Galileo and Buonamici on the Tides of the Sea: Was Something Omitted from the Dialogue?

A Historical Method Approach to Teaching Kepler's 2nd law

Galileo's Ship and the Relativity Principle

Physics for the masses: teaching Einsteinian gravity in primary school

The Starry Universe of Johannes Kepler

The Reception Of The Galilean Science Of Motion In Seventeenth-Century Europe.