Abstract:Medical Decision Making, Ahead of Print. BackgroundTo assess the impact of risk perceptions on prevention efforts or behavior change, best practices involve conditional risk measures, which ask people to estimate their risk contingent on a course of action (e.g., "if not vaccinated").PurposeTo determine whether the use of conditional wording—and its drawing of attention to one specific contingency—has an important downside that could lead researchers to overestimate the true relationship between perceptions of risk and intended prevention behavior.MethodsIn an online experiment, US participants from Amazon's MTurk (N = 750) were presented with information about an unfamiliar fungal disease and then randomly assigned among 3 conditions. In all conditions, participants were asked to estimate their risk for the disease (i.e., subjective likelihood) and to decide whether they would get vaccinated. In 2 conditional-wording conditions (1 of which involved a delayed decision), participants were asked about their risk if they did not get vaccinated. For an unconditional/benchmark condition, this conditional was not explicitly stated but was still formally applicable because participants had not yet been informed that a vaccine was even available for this disease.ResultsWhen people gave risk estimates to a conditionally worded risk question after making a decision, the observed relationship between perceived risk and prevention decisions was inflated (relative to in the unconditional/benchmark condition).ConclusionsThe use of conditionals in risk questions can lead to overestimates of the impact of perceived risk on prevention decisions but not necessarily to a degree that should call for their omission.HighlightsConditional wording, which is commonly recommended for eliciting risk perceptions, has a potential downside.It can produce overestimates of the true relationship between perceived risk and prevention behavior, as established in the current work.Though concerning, the biasing effect of conditional wording was small—relative to the measurement benefits that conditioning usually provides—and should not deter researchers from conditioning risk perceptions.More research is needed to determine when the biasing impact of conditional wording is strongest.

Causes and consequences of uncertainty about illness risk perceptions

Uncertainty Stress, and Its Impact on Disease Fear and Prevention Behavior During the COVID-19 Epidemic in China: A Panel Study.

Examining Intuitive Risk Perceptions For Cancer In Diverse Populations

Temporal Changes in Mental Response and Prevention Patterns, and Their Impact from Uncertainty Stress During the Transition in China from the COVID-19 Epidemic to Sporadic Infection

Eliciting Risk Perceptions: Does Conditional Question Wording Have a Downside?

Perception of future risk of breast cancer and coronary heart disease in female undergraduates

Lay views on uncertainty in environmental health risk assessment

The relationship between psychological states and health perception in individuals at risk for cardiovascular disease

The Association of Context with Reported Self-Efficacy for Cancer-Preventive Behaviors and Perceived Cancer Risk in U.S. Adults from the Midlife in the United States (MIDUS) Study

Lay beliefs about risk: relation to risk behaviors and to probabilistic risk perceptions

Cultural Worldviews and Perceived Risk of Colon Cancer and Diabetes

Engaging in Risky and Impulsive Behaviors to Alleviate Distress Mediates Associations Between Intolerance of Uncertainty and Externalizing Psychopathology

Uncertain futures: Individual risk and social context in decision-making in cancer screening

Low Health Literacy and Health Information Avoidance but Not Satisficing Help Explain "don't Know" Responses to Questions Assessing Perceived Risk.

A Metacognitive Approach to Reconsidering Risk Perceptions and Uncertainty: Understand Information Seeking During COVID-19

Uncertainty in healthcare and health decision making: Five methodological and conceptual research recommendations from an interdisciplinary team

Distinct computational mechanisms of uncertainty processing explain opposing exploratory behaviors in anxiety and apathy

Modeling Decision-Making in Schizophrenia: Associations Between Computationally Derived Risk Propensity and Self-Reported Risk Perception

A Cognitive-Ecological Perspective on Risk Perception and Medical Decision Making

Why fall for misinformation? Role of information processing strategies, health consciousness, and overconfidence in health literacy

Physical health mindsets and information avoidance