The promise of genes for understanding cause and effect

D. Conley,Simone Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1805585115

2018-05-21

Abstract:Since the 1980s, social scientists have become increasingly interested in how to make credible claims about cause and effect using observational data (1). Ignited by seminal papers demonstrating the promise of natural experiments (2), the causal revolution has put social scientists on the lookout for “as-if” random sources of variation in the world. The search for instrumental variables, discontinuities, and other naturally occurring randomizations has become a massive industry. But what if we had a large set of instrumental variables right under our skin, encoded in our genes? After all, our genes are a random draw of the genes of our parents, and many human behaviors and traits—from alcoholism to personality to political partisanship—have a genetic component. If we used the genotypes that influence, say, education, as an instrument for schooling completed, we might be able to figure out how much education causally affects wages net of confounders, like childhood nutrition, that affect both education and wages. One commonly adopted approach, Mendelian randomization (MR), deploys genes as instruments to unpack causal relationships in this way (3). In PNAS, DiPrete et al. (4) identify the conditions under which the identifying assumptions behind MR are not met and propose an alternative, genetic instrumental variables, which they argue makes it possible to credibly deploy genes as instruments. These efforts are important because if we could use genes as instrumental variables, we could make causal inferences about an expanded set of social and behavioral treatments and outcomes. And, because everyone has genes, we could study these relationships in broader populations, rather than be limited to highly local effects in narrow populations of compliers, as is often the case with many instruments today. These advantages, coupled with advances in the infrastructure to support research employing genetic data, mean that the payoff for figuring out how … [↵][1]1To whom correspondence should be addressed. Email: dconley{at}princeton.edu. [1]: #xref-corresp-1-1