Graduate and Postgraduate Diploma and Degree Programs in Clinical Laboratory Sciences

J. Alam
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/CCLM.2003.109
2003-01-15
Abstract:There has been an ongoing debate (1) on how to improve and facilitate the training programs for clinical laboratory personnel, either specialists or technicians/technologists. Several reports, letters, and insights were presented at different fora (2), in addition to detailed online information about training in Clinical Laboratory Sciences (CLS) (3–9), which is available for aspiring individuals who want to obtain a degree or diploma in this field to earn their livelihood. However, in spite of all advancement in training techniques and resources available in diagnostic technology, CLS still faces several problems, such as the dearth of required qualifications among persons actually performing the analytical procedures in clinical laboratories, be it medical graduates (known as doctors) or technologists (with a degree in Biological Sciences e.g., Bachelors of Science; BS). This occurs basically due to the lack of structured training programs and well-defined course content, in addition to overlapping of specialties and available teaching and training resources. In the present scenario worldwide, a medical or science degree (with the exception of pharmacy), with a postgraduate degree (PhD, MD, or equivalent qualification such as fellowship of Royal College of Pathologists, United Kingdom), or a postgraduate diploma (PGD) in science or pathology (10, 11) (where PhD or MD are not available) is required to achieve the status of a head of the department and/or to have the authority to sign laboratory reports (10, 12, 13). Furthermore, a graduate degree or a college degree with a certificate course or a university PGD in clinical laboratory sciences is mandatory to achieve the status of a technician or technologist, who performs the analytical procedures and writes reports (13). This Letter provides a brief insight into the types of teaching and training programs of Clinical Laboratory Sciences (CLS, also known as Diagnostic Laboratory Sciences; DLS) available in most of the medical centers and established hospitals in Pakistan. Moreover, feasibility of these programs to provide better laboratory personnel (and subsequent high quality services) and the symbiotic and professional relationship of those attaining degrees and diplomas through such programs, are also briefly discussed. Fuentes-Arderiu (12) recently suggested that CLS should be an independent university degree instead of a PGD or certificate course, which is equivalent in terms of exams, courses, and credit hours required for medicine, biology, and pharmacy degree programs. He also emphasized that clinical chemistry (and subsequently all clinical laboratory sciences) should only be for University graduates (12). Fuentes-Arderiu explained thoroughly the scenario, which leads to this conclusion. I agree with Fuentes-Arderiu’s opinion that CLS (or DLS) qualification should be at a graduate degree level, which would clearly solve many technical and management problems faced by the clinical laboratories on day-to-day basis. However, abolishment of PGD programs is not feasible, since it provides solace to those, who after acquiring graduate degree (either in medical or biological sciences), want to pursue their career as technologists or specialists in CLS. In Pakistan, the situation is similar in all large hospitals and medical centers with degree/diploma awarding status, such as ours. We have two types of CLS training programs (mentioned as model A and model B by FuentesArderiu) and therefore, two different cadres of clinical laboratory personnel. There is also a third one, which shall be discussed later. First cadre or type of CLS personnel are pathologists who spend 4–6 years obtaining graduate degree in medicine and 2–3 years obtaining PGD (Membership of the College of Physicians and Surgeons, MCPS) in laboratory sciences (specifically known as Pathology inclusive of biochemistry, microbiology, hematology, histopathology, parasitology, blood banking, serology, immunology, etc.). This PGD is awarded by a higher academic authority of the College of Physicians and Surgeons in Pakistan affiliated and accredited with Royal Colleges of England. Let’s call it Model I (it has been available since 1980s). The second staff category is a technologist, with a graduate degree (e.g., BS) in biological sciences with courses in biology, chemistry, biochemistry, microbiology, physiology etc., and a 2-year PGD in diagnostic laboratory sciences (known as PGDDLS), which allows gaining experience in the same subjects as in Model I, in addition to laboratory management, but excluding *E-mail of the corresponding author: dr_jmalam@hotmail.com; jma65@cyber.net.pk Letter to the Editor
What problem does this paper attempt to address?