Abstract:Forensic handwriting examiners (FHE) activities are focused on comparative analysis of handwritten objects such as signatures. Their role is to provide and evaluate evidence for and against the authenticity of a questioned signature. In recent years, cases involving handwritten signatures captured on electronic devices have become more commonplace. These so-called 'dynamic signatures' (also known as 'digitally captured signatures') are much different from paper-based signatures. Not only does the medium of recording differ, but also the type, volume of data and features are different from the pattern-based evidence that makes up paper-based signatures. Recent developments in forensic science - including signature examination - have led to the adoption of evaluative probabilistic methodologies in many disciplines [see, e.g. ENFSI 1915 Guidelines]. In the current paper, a probabilistic model to evaluate signature evidence in the form of multivariate data, as proposed and described in Wacom Europe GmbH (2019), is adopted. Topics like data sparsity, joint evaluation of multiple features and feature selection are investigated. Performed experimental studies showed an accuracy rate above 90% even when a limited number (5) of reference signatures was available. The performances of a multivariate approach are compared with those characterizing a so-called multiplicative approach where variables (features) are taken as independent and the Bayes' factor (BF) is obtained as the product of univariate BFs associated to each selected feature. The simplicity of this latter approach is, however, accompanied by severe issues about the reliability of results. The use of a multivariate approach is therefore highly recommended. Finally, the evidential values in correspondence of alternative feature sets are compared. Results suggest that discriminative features are writer-related and necessitate a case-specific selection.

Using Bayes factors to limit forensic testimony to forensics: composite hypotheses

The Role of the Bayes Factor in the Evaluation of Evidence

Generalized fiducial factor: an alternative to the Bayes factor for forensic identification of source problems

Defence Against the Modern Arts: the Curse of Statistics "Score-based likelihood ratios"

The Influence of Validation Data on Logical and Scientific Interpretations of Forensic Expert Opinions

Empirical Bayes factors for common hypothesis tests

Quantification of the weight of fingerprint evidence using a ROC-based Approximate Bayesian Computation algorithm for model selection

A Bayesian approach for the analysis of error rate studies in forensic science

A Note on the Specific Source Identification Problem in Forensic Science in the Presence of Uncertainty about the Background Population

Calculation of forensic likelihood ratios: Use of Monte Carlo simulations to compare the output of score-based approaches with true likelihood-ratio values

Sensitivity of inferences in forensic genetics to assumptions about founding genes

Calculating the Likelihood Ratio for Multiple Pieces of Evidence

Bayesian Reasoning and Evidence Communication

Bloodstain pattern analysis & Bayes: A case report

Psychometric analysis of forensic examiner behavior

Forensic identification: the Island Problem and its generalisations

Bayesian evaluation of dynamic signatures in operational conditions

A Good check on the Bayes factor

Demonstrative Evidence and the Use of Algorithms in Jury Trials

A Bayesian Hierarchical Model for Evaluating Forensic Footwear Evidence

The effects of cognitive bias, examiner expertise, and stimulus material on forensic evidence analysis