Abstract:With recent technological innovations, the multiplication of captured images of criminal events has brought the comparison of faces to the forefront of the judicial scene. Forensic face recognition has become a ubiquitous tool to guide investigations, gather intelligence and provide evidence in court. However, its reliability in court still suffers from the lack of methodological standardization and empirical validation, notably when using automatic systems, which compare images and generate a matching score. Although the use of such systems increases drastically, it still requires more empirical studies based on adequate forensic data (surveillance footage and identity documents) to become a reliable method to present evidence in court. In this paper, we propose a review of the literature leading to the establishment of a methodological workflow to develop a score-based likelihood-ratio computation model using a Bayesian framework. Different approaches are proposed in the literature regarding the within-source and between-sources variability distributions modelling. Depending on the data available, the modelling approach can be specific to the case or generic. Generic approaches allow interpreting the score without any available images of the suspect. Such model is henceforth harder to defend in court because the results are not anchored to the suspect. To make sure the computed score-based LR is robust, we must assess the performance of the model with two main characteristics: the discriminating power and the calibration state of the model. We hence describe the main metrics (Equal Error Rate and Cost of log likelihood-ratio), and graphical representations (Tippett plots, Detection Error Trade-off plot and Empirical Cross-Entropy plot) used to quantify and visualize the performance characteristics.

Forensic identification: the Island Problem and its generalisations

A Note on the Specific Source Identification Problem in Forensic Science in the Presence of Uncertainty about the Background Population

Generalized fiducial factor: an alternative to the Bayes factor for forensic identification of source problems

Using Bayes factors to limit forensic testimony to forensics: composite hypotheses

Sensitivity of inferences in forensic genetics to assumptions about founding genes

Defence Against the Modern Arts: the Curse of Statistics "Score-based likelihood ratios"

Evaluation of distance-based approaches for forensic comparison: Application to hand odor evidence

Interpreting forensic DNA mixtures: allowing for uncertainty in population substructure and dependence

Likelihood Ratios for physical traits in forensic investigations

A review of likelihood ratios in forensic science based on a critique of Stiffelman "No longer the Gold standard: Probabilistic genotyping is changing the nature of DNA evidence in criminal trials"

Automated face recognition in forensic science: Review and perspectives

A Statistical Approach to Crime Linkage

On forensic likelihood ratios from low-coverage sequencing

Calculation of forensic likelihood ratios: Use of Monte Carlo simulations to compare the output of score-based approaches with true likelihood-ratio values

Interpreting DNA mixtures with relatives of a missing suspect

A hybrid formal theory of arguments, stories and criminal evidence

Evaluating evidence in linked crimes with multiple offenders

A Logical Approach to Criminal Case Investigation

Lottery paradox, DNA evidence and other stories: How to accept uncertain statements

The statistical evaluation of DNA mixtures with contributors from different ethnic groups

A novel generalized similarity measure under intuitionistic fuzzy environment and its applications to criminal investigation