Abstract:Short-term predictions for dispersion of radionuclides in the atmosphere following releases from nuclear incidents are associated with uncertainties originating from meteorology, source term and parameterization. Characterization of these uncertainties is of key importance for preparedness, decision making during an accident and for the further uncertainty propagation in the subsequent modelling of human and ecosystem exposures. Increased traffic of nuclear-propulsion vessels in Norwegian territorial waters gives rise to growing concern of a potential nuclear accident along the coast of Norway. In the present study, we have quantified and inter-compared the uncertainties associated with the model outputs for a hypothetical loss of coolant accident with an ensuing fire in a nuclear vessel situated along the Norwegian coastline, applying two different atmospheric dispersion models: the SNAP Lagrangian particle model (SNAP-Severe Nuclear Accident Program) and the DIPCOT Lagrangian puff model (DIPCOT - Dispersion over Complex Terrain). The case highlights a situation with atmospheric transport from the offshore area to the coast of Western Norway, combined with large wet deposition in inland mountainous terrain, i.e. a common weather situation in this region. The meteorological data include an Ensemble Prediction System with nine ensemble members in addition to a deterministic base run. Five different 7 h emission scenarios with the same total released activity were considered. Hourly wind data at 10 m above ground for a 24 h period, showed that 36% of the wind direction and 41% of the wind speed data were outside the spread of the meteorological ensemble. About 55% and 13% of the measured values fell outside the ensemble for hourly 2 m above ground temperatures and 3 hourly accumulated precipitation, respectively, indicating that the ensemble did not cover all uncertainties in the meteorological fields. The maps of accumulated concentrations and depositions were qualitatively similar for the two models, but SNAP predicted higher accumulated concentration levels compared to DIPCOT for quite large areas, while DIPCOT yielded larger total depositions in the same areas. Furthermore, the direction, speed of movement and spatial extension of the radioactive plume from the accident varied considerably from one model to the other. The spread in the dispersion of the radionuclides ranged from a factor of about 1-3 in the source area to a factor of about 2-5 further away. The spreads due to meteorology and emission scenarios were of similar magnitude. Considering the ratio of the 50th percentiles of the two models, the spread varied by a factor of about 1-9, indicating that uncertainties arising from the formulation of the dispersion model could be as important or even larger than those associated with meteorology and emissions. Thus, it is recommended to include the uncertainty originating from the choice of the dispersion model into the overall uncertainty of short-term prediction of the dispersion of radionuclides and to exploit this further by generating an ensemble of several dispersion models.

Mid-range atmospheric dispersion modelling. Intercomparison of simple models in EMRAS-2 project

Combining short-range dispersion simulations with fine-scale meteorological ensembles: probabilistic indicators and evaluation during a 85Kr field campaign

An inverse method to estimate emission rates based on nonlinear least-squares-based ensemble four-dimensional variational data assimilation with local air concentration measurements

Uncertainties in short term prediction of atmospheric dispersion of radionuclides. A case study of a hypothetical accident in a nuclear floating power plant off the West coast of Norway

Estimation of the dispersion of an accidental release of radionuclides and toxic materials based on weather type classification

Model Intercomparison of Atmospheric 137cs from the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant Accident: Simulations Based on Identical Input Data

Radioactive Contamination Control by Atmospheric Dispersion Assessment of Airborne Indicator Contaminants: Numerical Model Validation

Predictability of the dispersion of Fukushima-derived radionuclides and their homogenization in the atmosphere

Modified Ensemble Kalman Filter for Nuclear Accident Atmospheric Dispersion: Prediction Improved and Source Estimated

Atmospheric 137cs Dispersion Following the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Accident: Local-scale Simulations Using CALMET and LAPMOD

Atmospheric dispersion of radioactive materials for radiological risk assessment in case of hypothetical sodium cooled fast reactor accident

Modeling and Sensitivity Analysis of Transport and Deposition of Radionuclides from the Fukushima Dai-Ichi Accident

Comparing model skills for deterministic versus ensemble dispersion modelling: The Fukushima Daiichi NPP accident as a case study

3rd model intercomparison projects of atmospheric dispersion model for 137Cs emitted from Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Plant, and application of MIPs' results for usage in an emergency

Methodology for analyzing dose consequence using atmospheric dispersion code A2CDOSE

Micro-SWIFT SPRAY modeling of atmospheric dispersion around a nuclear power plant site with complex topography

Simulations of Atmospheric Dispersion of Radioactive Materials with the Urban Canopy Model

Numerical simulation studies on the environment emergency response activity

Comparative analysis of the dispersion modeling and dose projection results performed under BARCO international project

A new dry deposition model implemented in CALPUFF code to simulate contamination of radionuclides released into atmospheric environment post-nuclear accidental event

Local Atmospheric Transport Behaviors of Representative Radionuclides During the Fukushima Accident: A 200-M-resolution Cross-Scale Study from Site to 20 Km