AI Across Borders: Exploring Perceptions and Interactions in Higher Education

Juliana Gerard,Sahajpreet Singh,Morgan Macleod,Michael McKay,Antoine Rivoire,Tanmoy Chakraborty,Muskaan Singh
2024-12-15
Abstract:This study investigates students' perceptions of Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI), with a focus on Higher Education institutions in Northern Ireland and India. We collect quantitative Likert ratings and qualitative comments from 1,211 students on their awareness and perceptions of AI and investigate variations in attitudes toward AI across institutions and subject areas, as well as interactions between these variables with demographic variables (focusing on gender). We find that: (a) while perceptions varied across institutions, responses for Computer Sciences students were similar; and (b) after controlling for institution and subject area, we observed no effect of gender. These results are consistent with previous studies, which find that students' perceptions are predicted by prior experience. We consider the implications of this relation and some considerations for the role of experience.
Computers and Society,Human-Computer Interaction
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **Perceptual differences among students in different higher education institutions and disciplinary fields regarding Generative AI (GenAI) and their influencing factors**. Specifically, the research aims to explore the following aspects: 1. **Perceptual differences across institutions and disciplinary fields**: - The research found that there are significant differences in students' perceptions of GenAI in different higher education institutions and disciplinary fields. These differences are reflected not only in qualitative comments but also in quantitative Likert scores. 2. **The relationship between perceptual differences and demographic variables**: - The research also explored how these perceptual differences interact with demographic variables (such as gender, age, etc.). The research results show that after controlling for institutions and disciplinary fields, the influence of gender on perception is not significant. 3. **The influence of experience on perception**: - Previous research has shown that students' prior experience is an important factor in predicting their perception of AI. This study further verifies this point and emphasizes the crucial role of experience in explaining perceptual differences. 4. **Cross - cultural comparison**: - The research selected two universities, Ulster University in Northern Ireland and the Indian Institute of Technology Delhi in India, for comparison to explore whether there are differences in students' perceptions of GenAI in different national and regional contexts. Through the above research, the author hopes to provide higher education institutions with a more comprehensive understanding of students' attitudes towards GenAI, thereby helping to formulate more effective support and training strategies and promoting the rational application of AI in education. ### Main conclusions - There are significant differences in students' perceptions of GenAI among different institutions and disciplinary fields. - These differences are influenced by students' prior experience, and gender has no significant influence on perception after controlling for other variables. - The comparison in cross - cultural contexts reveals different attitudes of students in different countries and regions towards GenAI, which provides a reference for international educational policy - making. ### Method overview The research adopted a combination of quantitative and qualitative methods, including: - **Quantitative part**: Use the Likert scale to rate students' awareness and perception of AI. - **Qualitative part**: Collect students' free - text comments on the use of AI in academics and conduct sentiment analysis and topic analysis. Through this method, researchers can more comprehensively understand students' attitudes towards GenAI and the driving factors behind them.