I would love this to be like an assistant, not the teacher: a voice of the customer perspective of what distance learning students want from an Artificial Intelligence Digital Assistant

Bart Rienties,John Domingue,Subby Duttaroy,Christothea Herodotou,Felipe Tessarolo,Denise Whitelock
2024-02-16
Abstract:With the release of Generative AI systems such as ChatGPT, an increasing interest in using Artificial Intelligence (AI) has been observed across domains, including higher education. While emerging statistics show the popularity of using AI amongst undergraduate students, little is yet known about students' perceptions regarding AI including self-reported benefits and concerns from their actual usage, in particular in distance learning contexts. Using a two-step, mixed-methods approach, we examined the perceptions of ten online and distance learning students from diverse disciplines regarding the design of a hypothetical AI Digital Assistant (AIDA). In the first step, we captured students' perceptions via interviews, while the second step supported the triangulation of data by enabling students to share, compare, and contrast perceptions with those of peers. All participants agreed on the usefulness of such an AI tool while studying and reported benefits from using it for real-time assistance and query resolution, support for academic tasks, personalisation and accessibility, together with emotional and social support. Students' concerns related to the ethical and social implications of implementing AIDA, data privacy and data use, operational challenges, academic integrity and misuse, and the future of education. Implications for the design of AI-tailored systems are also discussed.
Computers and Society,Artificial Intelligence
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the expectations and potential concerns of distance - learning students regarding the Artificial Intelligence Digital Assistant (AIDA). Specifically, the research aims to answer the following questions: 1. **What services do distance - learning students hope to obtain from the Artificial Intelligence Digital Assistant (AIDA)?** 2. **What potential concerns may students have when using AIDA?** ### Research Background With the release of generative AI systems (such as ChatGPT), the application of artificial intelligence in various fields has attracted wide - spread attention, including in higher education. Although data shows that undergraduate students widely use AI tools, there is still little known about students' views on AI, self - reported benefits, and concerns in actual use, especially in the distance - learning environment. ### Research Methods The research adopts a two - stage mixed - method design: - **First stage**: Collected the views of 10 distance - learning students from different disciplines through interviews. - **Second stage**: Further verified and supplemented the interview data through an online survey to ensure data triangulation. ### Main Findings According to the students' feedback, the main services they expect AIDA to provide include: 1. **Real - time assistance and query resolution**: - Students hope to be able to obtain 24/7 academic support, such as getting instant answers to questions and being provided with relevant resource links. - For example, one student mentioned: "24/7 support would be great because each of us has very different working hours." (I09) 2. **Academic task support**: - AIDA should be able to help students complete specific academic activities, such as summarizing the key points of study materials, providing feedback on learning activities, language support, and recommending additional study materials. - For example, non - native English - speaking students hope that AI can help them improve their grammar and writing. (I03) 3. **Personalization and barrier - free support**: - Students hope that AI can be customized according to their individual needs and provide support for students with special needs. - For example, one student mentioned: "If AI can tell me knowledge points that I don't know, it will be very useful." (IO6) 4. **Emotional and social support**: - For some students, the emotional and social support functions of AIDA are also important, especially when they feel lonely or stressed. - For example, students living in remote areas think that this kind of support may be helpful to them. (IO7) ### Potential Concerns The potential concerns of students about AIDA mainly include: - **Ethical and social impacts**: Worried that the implementation of AI will have a negative impact on society. - **Data privacy and use**: Worried about the security and privacy of personal data. - **Operational challenges**: Worried about technical difficulties and mis - use problems. - **Academic integrity**: Worried that relying on AI may lead to academic misconduct. - **The future of education**: Worried about whether AI will replace the role of human teachers and affect future education models. ### Conclusion This research emphasizes the importance of considering students' needs and concerns when designing AI digital assistants, and provides valuable insights for developing AI tools that are more in line with the needs of distance - learners.