Abstract:Ill-posed configurations, such as collinear or coplanar point arrangements, are a persistent challenge in computational geometry, complicating tasks as in triangulation and convex hull construction. This paper discusses the probability of such configurations arising in two scenarios: (1) data sampled randomly from a uniform distribution, and (2) data collected from physical systems, such as reflective surfaces or structured environments. We present a probabilistic framework, analyze the geometric and sampling constraints, and provide some mathematical insights into how data acquisition processes influence the likelihood of degeneracies. Notably, our findings reveal that degeneracies occur more frequently in physical systems than in purely random simulations due to systematic biases introduced by instrumental setups and environmental structures, emphasizing the risks of drawing conclusions solely based on assumptions derived from random data.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: the probability of the occurrence of degenerate configurations (such as collinear or coplanar point arrangements) and their impacts in random data and data collected from physical systems. Specifically:
1. **Definition and Importance of Degenerate Configurations**:
- Degenerate configurations, such as collinear or coplanar point arrangements, are an ongoing challenge in computational geometry and can complicate tasks such as triangulation and convex hull construction.
- These degenerate configurations can lead to numerical instability and pose significant challenges to problems such as the Smallest Enclosing Sphere (SES), convex hull construction, model surface reconstruction, and triangulation.
2. **Research Background**:
- In data sets randomly sampled from a uniform distribution, as the dimension increases, the probability of encountering these degeneracies decreases because high - dimensional space itself reduces the possibility of point alignment in low - dimensional subspaces.
- However, physical data collection methods (such as LiDAR or photogrammetry) introduce systematic biases, quantization effects, digitization, measurement noise, and environmental constraints, making degenerate phenomena more common. For example, the point cloud generated by a LiDAR sensor from an unmanned aerial system may exhibit inherent geometric regularities due to the structural properties of the scanning environment, resulting in collinear or coplanar point arrangements and complicating subsequent geometric calculations.
3. **Research Objectives**:
- This research aims to provide a comprehensive framework for comparing the probabilities of degenerate configurations occurring in purely random data and physical system data by integrating probability analysis and empirical observations in simulated scenarios.
- In particular, the research reveals that degenerate phenomena in physical systems are more frequent than in pure random simulations, mainly due to the systematic biases introduced by sensor geometry and environmental structure, emphasizing the risks of drawing conclusions based solely on random data assumptions.
4. **Specific Problem Statements**:
- The paper considers the probabilities of encountering degenerate configurations in two cases:
1. Points uniformly sampled from \([0, 1]^d\subset\mathbb{R}^d\), where each point \(p_i\) is independently drawn from the uniform distribution \(U(0, 1)\).
2. Data collected from simulated physical systems, where points \(p_i\) can be modeled as \(p_i = s_i+\epsilon_i\), where \(s_i\) lies on a structured surface \(S\subset\mathbb{R}^d\) and \(\epsilon_i\) represents noise.
5. **Research Methods**:
- By defining degenerate configurations (such as collinear, coplanar, and approximately spherical points) and using a probability framework to analyze the probabilities of these configurations occurring in random data and physical system data.
- Provide specific mathematical derivations, analyze the degenerate probabilities under different dimensions and numbers of points, and verify the theoretical results through experiments.
In summary, the goal of this paper is to gain an in - depth understanding, through probability analysis and experimental verification, of how the data collection process affects the occurrence of degenerate configurations, especially the reasons why degenerate phenomena are more prevalent in physical systems. This helps in designing more robust geometric calculation algorithms, especially when dealing with real - world data.