Abstract:Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems are increasingly deployed in all domains of our lives. While their use can provide substantial benefits, they also entail significant risks – and ethics has been put forward as the key solution to counter these risks. Yet the manner in which ethics is typically relied on in this context is woefully deficient. At best, ethics is given the role of orienting problematic technology towards ‘acceptable’ uses, thereby legitimizing AI’s widespread adoption, which is taken for granted. At worst, ethics is instrumentalized as a quality-label to stimulate AI’s deployment, as part of a broader doctrine of ‘progress’. Current ethics discourse hence appears unable to provide a more fundamental critique of the way in which the algorithmized world is profoundly impacting our existence. This is because it starts from within a technological paradigm that does not fundamentally question AI’s place and progression in society. In this paper, I therefore argue that, if ethics is to shed light on – and to offer a more fundamental critique of – the human condition in an algorithmized world, without being bound to today’s technological paradigm, it requires a meta-technological perspective that puts ethics first. To pursue this aim, I propose to ground our approach in the fact that our existence in the world is necessarily intersubjective and relational, and use the lens of intersubjectivity to examine AI’s impact on the human condition. To narrow the scope of my analysis, I focus on AI’s impact on three interrelated domains of our existence: (1) our way of thinking or rationality, (2) our way of engaging with others or alterity and (3) our way of experiencing time or history. In my analysis, I draw on the work of 20th-century Jewish thinkers, such as Franz Rosenzweig, Emmanuel Levinas and Hannah Arendt, given the importance they ascribe to relationality and its role in countering totalitarian thinking which, as I argue, can also arise through the systemic irresponsible use of AI. After introducing my research inquiry (Chapter 1) and providing a brief definition of AI (Chapter 2), I seek to answer three questions: First, what does the algorithmized world look like, and what is its underpinning societal paradigm (Chapter 3)? Second, how does current AI ethics discourse approach AI’s risks, and how does it fall short of delivering a more fundamental critique of AI’s impact on the human condition (Chapter 4)? Third, how does AI’s ubiquity affect the human condition, and particularly our experience of rationality, alterity and history (Chapter 5)? Based on my research findings, I conclude that the totalizing use of AI systems – and the way it impacts our way of thinking, our way of engaging with others and our way of experiencing time – can give rise to significant concerns, as it may be used in a way that opposes our ability to live a meaningful life by engaging in intersubjective human relationships. To close this paper, I postulate several avenues that should be explored to counter the concerns identified (Chapter 6).

The Method of Critical AI Studies, A Propaedeutic

A Critical Historic Overview of Artificial Intelligence: Issues, Challenges, Opportunities and Threats

Different approaches to the moral status of AI: a comparative analysis of paradigmatic trends in Science and Technology Studies

AI for the Common Good?! Pitfalls, challenges, and Ethics Pen-Testing

Automating Ambiguity: Challenges and Pitfalls of Artificial Intelligence

The Human Condition in An Algorithmized World: A Critique through the Lens of 20th-Century Jewish Thinkers and the Concepts of Rationality, Alterity and History

Artificial Tikkun Olam: AI Can Be Our Best Friend in Building an Open Human-Computer Society

A toolkit of dilemmas: Beyond debiasing and fairness formulas for responsible AI/ML

The scienthetic method: from Aristotle to AI and the future of medicine

Critical Posthumanist Literacy: Building Theory for Reading, Writing, and Living Ethically with Everyday Artificial Intelligence

Closing the AI Knowledge Gap

A Methodology for Ethics-by-Design AI Systems: Dealing with Human Value Conflicts

Artificial Intelligence Inheriting the Historical Crisis in Psychology: An Epistemological and Methodological Investigation of Challenges and Alternatives

The ethics of algorithms from the perspective of the cultural history of consciousness: first look

Criticizing Ethics According to Artificial Intelligence

The influence of artificial intelligence within health-related risk work: a critical framework and lines of empirical inquiry

A Framework for Critical Evaluation of Text-to-Image Models: Integrating Art Historical Analysis, Artistic Exploration, and Critical Prompt Engineering

Problems in AI, their roots in philosophy, and implications for science and society

Artificial Intelligence And The Scientific Method: How To Cope With A Complete Oxymoron

A Paradigm Shift in Research: Exploring the Intersection of Artificial Intelligence and Research Methodology

AI Ethics: A Bibliometric Analysis, Critical Issues, and Key Gaps