Abstract:Artificial intelligence (AI) ethics has emerged as a burgeoning yet pivotal area of scholarly research. This study conducts a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of the AI ethics literature over the past two decades. The analysis reveals a discernible tripartite progression, characterized by an incubation phase, followed by a subsequent phase focused on imbuing AI with human-like attributes, culminating in a third phase emphasizing the development of human-centric AI systems. After that, they present seven key AI ethics issues, encompassing the Collingridge dilemma, the AI status debate, challenges associated with AI transparency and explainability, privacy protection complications, considerations of justice and fairness, concerns about algocracy and human enfeeblement, and the issue of superintelligence. Finally, they identify two notable research gaps in AI ethics regarding the large ethics model (LEM) and AI identification and extend an invitation for further scholarly research.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the development process, key issues, and research gaps in artificial intelligence ethics. Specifically:
1. **Development process**: Through comprehensive bibliometric analysis, the paper explores the development process of artificial intelligence ethics in the past two decades. The author reveals an obvious three - stage process, including:
- **Incubation period (2004 - 2013)**: During this period, AI ethics research was scattered in multiple related fields, such as information ethics, machine ethics, and robot ethics. Keywords such as "personality", "friendly AI", and "anthropocentrism" reflect the initial discussion of the status of AI.
- **Making AI machines like humans (2014 - 2019)**: During this period, the focus of AI ethics research shifted to endowing AI with human - like attributes, such as fairness, transparency, and interpretability.
- **Making AI human - centered machines (2020 - present)**: During this period, the focus of AI ethics research has shifted to reducing bias, supporting diversity, increasing transparency and credibility, emphasizing the human - centered development of AI technology.
2. **Key issues**: The paper proposes seven key AI ethical issues, which are hot and difficult points in current research, including:
- **Collingridge dilemma**: When it is easy to change, the need for change cannot be foreseen; when the need for change is obvious, change becomes expensive, difficult, and time - consuming.
- **AI status debate**: Is AI a moral - influence agent, an implicit moral agent, an explicit moral agent, or a fully moral agent?
- **AI transparency and interpretability**: How to strike a balance between full interpretability and partial transparency.
- **Privacy protection**: In the AI era, privacy is eroded on an unprecedented scale and depth.
- **Justice and fairness**: Problems of injustice, unfairness, and bias stem from deep - rooted cultural and historical realities.
- **Algorithmic rule and human weakening**: The influence of AI and algorithms has weakened democracy and marginalized the majority.
- **Super - intelligence**: The unknown consequences and potential existential risks of creating super - intelligence.
3. **Research gaps**: The paper points out two significant research gaps:
- **Large - scale ethical model (LEM)**: AI ethics research can learn from the methods of large - language models (LLM) and break free from the constraints of traditional theories, principles, and frameworks.
- **AI identification**: Identify and evaluate AI instances through innovative methods to eliminate the mystery and ambiguity of AI.
In summary, this paper aims to systematically sort out the development process of AI ethics through bibliometric analysis and the discussion of key issues, and point out the direction and focus of future research.