Path to Low-Cost Direct Air Capture

Peter Eisenberger,Matthew Realff

2024-11-23

Abstract:It is now accepted that gigatonnes of Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) from the atmosphere are needed to avoid the threat of catastrophic climate change. Direct Air Capture (DAC) is a promising scalable CDR with a relatively small environmental footprint. But questions about DAC cost and energy use remain that are delaying the needed DAC policy decisions to create a mobilization effort like was done in the Manhattan Project and to address the Covid crisis. Global Thermostat (GT) has publicly claimed costs of under 50 dollars per tonne for mature GT technology deployed at a climate relevant scale. Why this low DAC cost is achievable will be addressed by a simplified analysis of generic DAC costs and using that analysis combined with experimental data to evaluate GT's DAC technology. A detailed cost analysis of different approaches to DAC by the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) found an approach to DAC that had a learning cost limit as low as 25 dollars per tonne GT's DAC technology will be shown in Appendix 1 to have the same performance characteristics of the lowest-cost DAC identified in the NAS study. Thus, like solar costs, DAC costs can be reduced by learning by doing, but in the case of DAC, only one order of magnitude in cost reduction is needed. Therefore DAC technology can reach its low learning by doing cost limit at a scale much smaller than necessary to address climate change. From a climate perspective, current DAC embodiments costs and scale have less relevance than their learning curve cost limit. While GT's technology has demonstrated the crucial performance parameters to achieve a low-cost DAC, no inference should be drawn that other approaches cannot achieve low or lower cost, if they can demonstrate the crucial performance parameters. Continued R&D on those performance parameters is needed.

Physics and Society,Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the cost and energy use of Direct Air Capture (DAC) technology. Specifically, the paper explores how to achieve low - cost DAC through technical and economic analysis, enabling it to be applied on a large scale to counter the threat of climate change. The paper points out that although DAC is considered a promising large - scale Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) method, the uncertainties in its cost and energy use have hindered policy - makers from supporting and promoting it. Therefore, the main objective of the paper is to present an economically viable DAC path, that is, under reasonable assumptions, the cost of DAC can be reduced to less than $50 per ton of carbon dioxide, and this low - cost path is ready for large - scale production.

The paper explores this problem in the following aspects:

1. **Cost Analysis**: The paper provides a simplified cost - analysis model for evaluating the costs of different DAC technologies. This model takes into account factors such as capital expenditure (CAPEX), operating expenditure (OPEX), and energy consumption, aiming to determine the key performance parameters for achieving low - cost DAC.

2. **Experimental Data Support**: The paper uses experimental data to evaluate the DAC technology of Global Thermostat (GT), showing that this technology has demonstrated the key performance parameters required to achieve low - cost DAC.

3. **Technical Path**: The paper discusses the technical paths for achieving low - cost DAC, including key factors such as reducing air - flow resistance, increasing the surface area of the contact surface, accelerating the CO2 contact rate and kinetic rate, using low - temperature heat energy, and maximizing the adsorption time.

4. **Policy Recommendations**: The paper emphasizes the importance of taking immediate action and calls for a global mobilization effort similar to the Manhattan Project or the response to the COVID - 19 pandemic to accelerate the development and deployment of DAC technology, thereby effectively countering the threat of climate change.

In summary, the core issue of this paper is to prove, through technical and economic analysis, that DAC technology can achieve low - cost in the future and has the potential for large - scale application, thus providing an effective solution to climate change.