Can Alice do science and have friends, in a relational quantum world? Solipsism and Relational Quantum Mechanics

Carlo Rovelli

2024-10-26

Abstract:I discuss recent claims according to which relational understandings of quantum physics would undermine the credibility of science.

Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problem does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper attempts to solve the problem of whether Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM) undermines scientific credibility. Specifically, the author Carlo Rovelli explores the following points:

1. **The relationship between Relational Quantum Mechanics and solipsism**:
- Some scholars claim that RQM would lead to an epistemic solipsism, that is, a rational agent cannot rely on the observations of other agents. This may threaten the collective research and communication in science.
- The paper discusses these views and refutes the possibility that RQM would undermine science.

2. **The basis of science and communication**:
- RQM holds that all facts are relative, not absolute. Therefore, some people are worried that this relativity will destroy the common factual basis required by science.
- Through analysis, the author points out that science does not need absolute facts, but can conduct effective collective research and communication on the basis of relative facts.

3. **The nature of communication**:
- The author distinguishes between two meanings of "communication":
- **Direct access to the relative facts of others** (communicating1)
- **What we actually mean by communication in daily language** (communicating2)
- RQM does not impede communication in the second sense, which is necessary for scientific and social interactions.

4. **Scientific practice from a historical perspective**:
- The author emphasizes that we should focus on how science is actually carried out, rather than presetting the standards of what is "real" or "objective".
- Historically, science has developed by constantly revising its understanding of "real" and "objective", just as Copernicus' heliocentric theory replaced the geocentric theory.

5. **Weak realism and physical perspectivism**:
- RQM requires a weaker form of realism, that is, all statements about the state of reality are relative to a certain physical system.
- This perspectivism allows us to conduct scientific research and communication effectively without relying on absolute facts.

### Summary

The core problem of the paper is to explore whether and how RQM affects the credibility and feasibility of science. Through detailed analysis and analogy, the author demonstrates that even within the RQM framework, scientists can still conduct effective scientific research, exchange information, and establish friendships.