Relational objectivity in presence of finite quantum resources

Luis C. Barbado,Časlav Brukner

2024-07-05

Abstract:The no-go theorems of Bell and Kochen and Specker could be interpreted as implying that the notions of system and experimental context are fundamentally inseparable. In this interpretation, statements such as "spin is 'up' along direction $x$" are relational statements about the configurations of macroscopic devices which are mediated by the spin and not about any intrinsic properties of the spin. The operational meaning of these statements is provided by the practically infinite resources of macroscopic devices that serve to define the notion of a direction in three-dimensional space. This is the subject of "textbook quantum mechanics": The description of quantum systems in relation to an experimental context.. Can one go beyond that? Relational quantum mechanics endeavors to provide a relational description between any quantum systems without the necessity of involving macroscopic devices. However, by applying "textbook quantum mechanics" in such situations, it implicitly assumes infinite resources, even for simple quantum systems such as spins, which have no capacity to define an experimental context. This leads to conceptual difficulties. We analyse Penrose's spin network proposal as a potential formalisation of quantum theory that goes beyond the textbook framework: A description in presence of finite resources, which is inherently relational and inseparable in the system-context entity.

Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is the fundamental understanding of the relationship between systems and experimental contexts in quantum mechanics. Specifically, the paper explores how to provide a method of relationship description that goes beyond the traditional quantum mechanics framework under the condition of limited quantum resources. Traditional quantum mechanics assumes the existence of infinite macroscopic device resources to define concepts such as directions, and these assumptions will lead to conceptual difficulties when dealing with simple quantum systems such as spins. Therefore, the paper analyzes Penrose's spin - network proposal as a possible method of formalizing quantum theory, which can provide an intrinsically related and indivisible system - context entity description under the condition of limited resources.

### Main contributions of the paper
1. **Re - examining relational objectivity**: The paper emphasizes that all physics statements are in the form of propositions based on classical concepts. This is not only a common practice, but also, according to Bohr, is necessary for understanding and communicating laboratory measurement results. However, this description method brings challenges in quantum mechanics because the properties of quantum systems are closely related to their measurement contexts and cannot exist independently.

2. **Specific case of spin - projection measurement**: Through a specific spin - projection measurement case, the paper shows how to derive the description of "spin is up along the direction \(\vec{n}\)" from experimental arrangements and observation results. The paper points out that this description actually depends on the direction definition provided by macroscopic devices, rather than the intrinsic properties of the quantum system itself.

3. **Relational description in quantum mechanics**: The paper discusses the relational description in quantum mechanics, especially the view of Relational Quantum Mechanics (RQM). RQM believes that the properties of quantum systems are meaningful only relative to other systems, and this view is consistent with Bell's and Kochen - Specker's theorems. However, when RQM attempts to expand the traditional quantum mechanics framework, it encounters the problem of insufficient resources, resulting in conceptual inconsistency.

4. **Proposal of spin - network**: In order to overcome the problem of insufficient resources in RQM, the paper analyzes Penrose's spin - network proposal. The spin - network reconstructs the spatial structure through combination rules (such as addition and subtraction of total angular momentum) without presupposing the existence of space. This method aims to provide a new method for describing quantum systems and their context relationships under the condition of limited resources.

### Formula examples
- **Spin alignment probability**:
\[
p=\cos^{2}\left(\frac{\theta}{2}\right)
\]
where \(\theta\) is the angle between two directions \(\vec{n}\) and \(\vec{m}\).

### Conclusion
By analyzing the limitations of traditional quantum mechanics and RQM, the paper proposes the spin - network as a new formalization method to solve the problem of describing quantum systems and their context relationships under the condition of limited resources. This method not only helps to understand the relational objectivity in quantum mechanics more deeply, but also provides a new direction for future research.