A method to estimate well flowing gas-oil ratio and composition using pressure and temperature measurements across a production choke, a seed composition of oil and gas, and a thermodynamic simulator

Seok Ki Moon,Milan Stanko

2024-10-02

Abstract:In this work we propose and demonstrate a method to estimate the flowing gas-oil ratio and composition of a hydrocarbon well stream using measurements of pressure and temperature across a production choke. The method consists of using a numerical solver on a thermodynamic simulator to recombine a seed oil and gas until the simulated temperature drop across the choke is equal to the measured value. This method is meant for cases where it is not possible to measure periodically individual well composition. A study case and reference solution were generated using the reservoir model presented in the SPE (Society of Petroleum Engineers) comparative case Nr. 5 linked with a process simulator. Time profiles of well producing gas-oil ratio, wellstream compositions, compositions of surface conditions oil and gas, and temperature drop across the choke were generated with the models. The method proposed was then employed to estimate the flowing gas-oil ratio of the reference solution. Results show that the proposed method predicts with reasonable accuracy (maximum 12% percent error) the well gas-oil ratio and compositions during the life of the field when using compositions of surface oil and gas from initial time. When using compositions of surface oil and gas from later times, the prediction accuracy of the gas-oil ratio improves at those times but worsens for times before and after. A measurement error for the temperature drop across the choke of at least 0.01 °C is required to achieve convergence of the method. The mean percent error between the predicted and real mole fractions has an upper bound in time of 21% when using initial surface oil and gas as seed compositions.

Computational Engineering, Finance, and Science,Applied Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to use the pressure and temperature measurement data upstream and downstream of the production choke valve to estimate the gas - oil ratio (GOR) and composition of wellhead fluids when it is not possible to regularly measure the fluid composition of individual wells (for example, subsea wells produce through common pipelines). Specifically, the author proposes a method that uses initially or periodically collected oil and gas samples as "seed" components and combines a thermodynamic simulator. Through a numerical solver, the proportion of the seed oil and gas is adjusted so that the simulated downstream temperature of the choke valve matches the actual measured value, thereby calculating the gas - oil ratio and composition of the wellhead fluid.

### Method Overview

1. **Problem Background**:
- In many cases, especially for subsea wells, it is impractical or too costly to regularly measure the fluid composition of individual wells.
- Traditional fluid sampling methods involve significant costs and may require shutting down production wells, resulting in revenue loss.
- Surface samples are relatively easy to collect, but for a network of multiple wells and mixed production, sampling of individual wells may be unrealistic.

2. **Proposed Solution**:
- Use the pressure and temperature measurement data upstream and downstream of the production choke valve.
- Use initially or periodically collected oil and gas samples as "seed" components.
- Assume that the expansion process within the choke valve is an isenthalpic process.
- Use a thermodynamic simulator and a numerical solver to adjust the proportion of the seed oil and gas until the simulated downstream temperature of the choke valve is consistent with the actual measured value.

3. **Research Objectives**:
- Provide a reliable method for estimating the gas - oil ratio and composition of wellhead fluids when it is not possible to regularly measure the fluid composition of individual wells.
- Support virtual metering schemes, especially in production systems where fluid sampling is difficult.
- Determine the optimal fluid sampling interval to update the seed components and improve prediction accuracy.

### Results and Conclusions

- **Accuracy**: When using the surface oil and gas at the initial time as seed components, this method can predict the gas - oil ratio and composition throughout the life cycle of the oil field with high accuracy (maximum error of 12%).
- **Convergence Conditions**: In order to achieve the convergence of the method, the accuracy of the temperature sensor must reach 0.01°C or lower.
- **Impact of Seed Component Selection**: Using seed components close to the time point of the maximum gas - oil ratio can significantly improve prediction accuracy, but will reduce the accuracy at early and late time points.
- **Application Prospects**: This method can be applied to determine the flowing water cut rate or condensate water ratio, not just the gas - oil ratio.

### Formula Representation

- The gas - oil ratio (GOR) is defined as the ratio of the gas volume to the oil volume under standard conditions:
\[
\text{GOR}=\frac{V_{\text{gas}}}{V_{\text{oil}}}\quad(\text{Sm}^3 / \text{Sm}^3)
\]
- The mole fractions of the seed components are represented as \(x_i\) and \(y_i\), corresponding to the surface liquid and gas components respectively:
\[
z_i = f_g y_i+(1 - f_g)x_i
\]
where \(f_g\) is the mole ratio of the seed gas to the total mole flow rate.

Through this method, researchers are able to provide a reliable alternative for estimating the gas - oil ratio and composition of wellhead fluids when it is not possible to directly measure the well fluid composition.