Abstract:A one-third monolayer of the heavy metals Sn and Pb deposited on semiconductor substrates can lead to a $\sqrt{3}\times\sqrt{3}$ surface reconstruction, constituting an exciting triangular lattice material platform. A long history of experiments identified charge-ordered and magnetic ground states. These discoveries were accompanied by a decades-long debate of whether electron correlations or other effects involving phonons are the driving force of the symmetry-broken states. The most recent discovery of superconductivity in boron-doped Sn/Si(111) with a $T_c$ between 5K and 9K led to a renewed excitement. Here we revisit the electronic and phononic properties of Sn and Pb adatom triangular lattices on Si(111) and SiC(0001). For all materials we compute relativistic bandstructures using DFT+$U$ where $U$ is only applied to the substrate atoms in order to adjust the band gap to match the experimental value; as a consequence, some of the resulting tight-binding parameters of the metallic surface band differ substantially compared to previous studies. Remarkably, for Pb/SiC(0001) we predict Rashba spin-orbit coupling as large as 45% of the nearest-neighbor hopping energy. In addition, we compute the phonon spectra and electron-phonon coupling constants for all materials, and for Pb/Si(111) even relativistically although the inclusion of spin-orbit coupling has surprisingly little effect on the electron-phonon coupling constant. We conclude that the resulting couplings are too weak to account for electron-phonon mediated superconductivity in any of these materials.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to re - examine and analyze the electronic structure, spin - orbit coupling (SOC), and electron - phonon coupling (EPC) of Sn and Pb triangular lattice adatom layers formed on semiconductor substrates. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following issues: 1. **Electronic structure and spin - orbit coupling**: - Recalculate the relativistic band structures of Sn and Pb on Si(111) and SiC(0001) using the DFT + U method, with special attention to the strength of SOC. - Extract accurate band parameters through the tight - binding model to provide a basis for future many - body analyses. 2. **Phonon spectra and electron - phonon coupling**: - Calculate the phonon spectra of these materials and evaluate the strength of EPC. - Pay special attention to the relativistic EPC calculation of Pb/Si(111) to explore the influence of SOC on EPC. 3. **Discussion of superconducting mechanisms**: - Evaluate whether EPC is sufficient to explain the superconducting phenomena in these materials. - Explore whether electron - electron interactions may be the main driving force for superconductivity. ### Main findings 1. **Electronic structure**: - Through DFT + U calculations, it is found that the SOC strengths of different materials vary significantly, ranging from 10% to 45%. - Accurate tight - binding parameters are extracted, and it is found that there are large differences from the results in previous literature. The main reason is that the U term is introduced in DFT calculations to adjust the band gap. 2. **Phonon spectra and EPC**: - The phonon spectra of all materials are calculated, and it is found that the phonon mode with the lowest frequency contributes the most to EPC. - Calculate the EPC strength λ by the deformation potential method, and find that the λ values of all materials are small and not sufficient to drive conventional superconductivity. 3. **Superconducting mechanism**: - Estimate Tc through the Allen - Dynes equation, and find that EPC cannot explain the superconducting phenomenon in Sn/Si(111). - The conclusion is that the superconductivity experimentally observed in Sn/Si(111) may be driven by electron - electron interactions, which is in line with the chiral d - wave superconducting type proposed in recent experiments. ### Conclusion Through a detailed analysis of the electronic structure, SOC, and EPC of Sn and Pb on Si(111) and SiC(0001), the paper concludes that the EPC strength is too small to explain the superconducting phenomena in these materials. Therefore, superconductivity is more likely to be driven by electron - electron interactions, which is consistent with recent experimental results. In addition, the tight - binding parameters provided by the paper provide an important basis for future quantum many - body calculations.

Electronic structure, spin-orbit interaction and electron-phonon coupling of triangular adatom lattices on semiconductor substrates

Phonon-induced electronic relaxation in a strongly correlated system: the Sn/Si(111) $(\sqrt 3 \times \sqrt 3)$ adlayer revisited

Stability Of The Bi2se3(111) Topological State: Electron-Phonon And Electron-Defect Scattering

Realizing a Superconducting Square-Lattice Bismuth Monolayer

Doping-dependent charge- and spin-density wave orderings in a monolayer of Pb adatoms on Si(111)

Engineering correlated Dirac fermions and flat bands on SiC with transition-metal adatom lattices

Dirac surface states, multiorbital dimerization and superconductivity in Nb- and Ta-based A15 compounds

Electron-phonon Coupling and Nontrivial Band Topology in Noncentrosymmetric Superconductors LaNiSi, LaPtSi, and LaPtGe

Orbital selectivity in Sn adatom adlayer on a Si(111) surface

Crystal Symmetry, Electron-Phonon Coupling, and Superconducting Tendencies in Li$_2$Pd$_3$B and Li$_2$Pt$_3$B

Enhancing Electron Coherence via Quantum Phonon Confinement in Atomically Thin Nb3SiTe6

Strong Coupling and Periodic Potential at the Pb/Sb(111) Interface

Triangular Mott-Hubbard Insulator Phases of Sn/Si(111) and Sn/Ge(111) Surfaces

Alkali-metal induced electronic structure evolution in Sn4Sb3 studied by angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy

Interface Electronic Structure, Two-Dimensional Metallicity, and Possible Interface Superconductivity in Cucl/Si Superlattices

Surface Phase Transitions Induced by Electron Mediated Adatom-Adatom Interaction.

Unconventional superconductivity from electronic dipole fluctuations

Topological Dirac semimetal phases in InSb/$\alpha$-Sn semiconductor superlattices

Structural, Vibrational and Electronic Properties of Single Layer Hexagonal Crystals of Groups IV and V

Electron-phonon Coupling and Kohn Anomaly due to the Floating 2D Electronic Bands on the Surface of ZrSiS