How will advanced AI systems impact democracy?

Christopher Summerfield,Lisa Argyle,Michiel Bakker,Teddy Collins,Esin Durmus,Tyna Eloundou,Iason Gabriel,Deep Ganguli,Kobi Hackenburg,Gillian Hadfield,Luke Hewitt,Saffron Huang,Helene Landemore,Nahema Marchal,Aviv Ovadya,Ariel Procaccia,Mathias Risse,Bruce Schneier,Elizabeth Seger,Divya Siddarth,Henrik Skaug Sætra,MH Tessler,Matthew Botvinick

2024-08-27

Abstract:Advanced AI systems capable of generating humanlike text and multimodal content are now widely available. In this paper, we discuss the impacts that generative artificial intelligence may have on democratic processes. We consider the consequences of AI for citizens' ability to make informed choices about political representatives and issues (epistemic impacts). We ask how AI might be used to destabilise or support democratic mechanisms like elections (material impacts). Finally, we discuss whether AI will strengthen or weaken democratic principles (foundational impacts). It is widely acknowledged that new AI systems could pose significant challenges for democracy. However, it has also been argued that generative AI offers new opportunities to educate and learn from citizens, strengthen public discourse, help people find common ground, and to reimagine how democracies might work better.

Computers and Society,Artificial Intelligence

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the possible impacts of advanced artificial intelligence systems (especially generative AI) on democratic systems. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Epistemic Impacts**:
- The paper explores how AI affects citizens' ability to acquire and process political information and how these changes affect their ability to make informed choices. For example, AI may spread misinformation or generate highly persuasive political propaganda, thus weakening voters' autonomous decision - making ability. However, AI can also improve the epistemic health of democratic systems by providing accurate, balanced information, automating fact - checking, etc.

2. **Material Impacts**:
- The paper discusses how AI may be used to attack the infrastructure that supports democratic procedures (such as the election process) or unfairly deprive voters of their rights. But at the same time, AI can also improve governance efficiency, help policy - makers make better use of data, and provide citizens with accurate information about their rights.

3. **Foundational Impacts**:
- The paper analyzes how AI may weaken or strengthen the basic principles of democracy, including freedom, equality, and inclusiveness. For example, AI may reduce human responsibility, marginalize minority groups, increase improper surveillance or other forms of state oppression, or change the distribution of power and wealth, thus threatening the foundation of democracy. On the other hand, AI may also significantly improve the democratic experience by massively integrating diverse viewpoints and promoting broader citizen participation.

In summary, this paper aims to comprehensively assess the multi - faceted impacts of generative AI on democratic systems and explore how to address these challenges to ensure that AI technology can promote rather than undermine the democratic process.