Zero Flux Localization: Magic Revealed

Alireza Parhizkar,Victor Galitski

2024-09-10

Abstract:Flat bands correspond to the spatial localization of a quantum particle moving in a field with discrete or continuous translational invariance. The canonical example is the flat Landau levels in a homogeneous magnetic field. Several significant problems -- including flat bands in moiré structures -- are related to the problem of a particle moving in an inhomogeneous magnetic field with zero total flux. We demonstrate that while perfectly flat bands in such cases are impossible, the introduction of a "non-Abelian component" -- a spin field with zero total curvature -- can lead to perfect localization. Several exactly solvable models are constructed: (i) a half-space up/down field with a sharp 1D boundary; (ii) an alternating up/down field periodic in one direction on a cylinder; and (iii) a doubly periodic alternating field on a torus. The exact solution on the torus is expressed in terms of elliptic functions. It is shown that flat bands are only possible for certain magic values of the field corresponding to a quantized flux through an individual tile. These exact solutions clarify the simple structure underlying flat bands in moiré materials and provide a springboard for constructing a novel class of fractional quantum Hall states.

Strongly Correlated Electrons,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Mathematical Physics,Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether quantum particles can form flat bands in the case of zero total magnetic flux. Specifically, the author explores whether there are highly degenerate dispersion - free energy levels (i.e., flat bands) in a non - uniform magnetic field, especially when the total magnetic flux in the entire system is zero. This problem is of great significance for understanding physical phenomena in time - reversal symmetric systems (such as bilayer graphene and transition - metal dichalcogenides TMDs), because flat bands are known to appear in these systems under certain field configurations.

### Main research questions:
1. **Possibility of flat bands under zero total magnetic flux**: Are there flat bands in a non - uniform magnetic field with zero total magnetic flux?
2. **Influence of non - Abelian components**: Can perfect localization be achieved by introducing a spin field (a non - Abelian component) with zero total curvature?
3. **Construction of specific models and analytical solutions**: Construct several specific models and provide exact analytical solutions for these models to reveal the formation mechanism of flat bands.

### Specific research content:
- **Classical background**: The paper first reviews the classical case where electrons form flat bands in a uniform magnetic field, namely Landau levels. In a uniform magnetic field, the energy levels of electrons are independent of momentum, so they are spatially localized.
- **Challenges in non - uniform magnetic fields**: In a non - uniform magnetic field, due to the breaking of translational symmetry, momentum is no longer a good quantum number, so the existence of flat bands becomes complicated. Especially when the total magnetic flux is zero, classical trajectory analysis shows that localization is impossible.
- **Quantum mechanical perspective**: Through quantum mechanical analysis, the author finds that even when the total magnetic flux is zero, localization can still be achieved by introducing a non - Abelian component (spin field). This leads to the formation of flat bands.
- **Specific models**:
- **Half - space model**: Consider a half - space model where the magnetic field direction flips at a one - dimensional boundary.
- **Cylinder model**: Construct a periodic alternating magnetic field model on a cylinder.
- **Torus model**: Construct a doubly - periodic alternating magnetic field model on a torus and give an exact solution using elliptic functions.
- **Mathematical analysis**: By solving the Dirac equation and the Schrödinger equation, the author analyzes in detail the wave functions and energy spectra in these models and reveals the conditions for the formation of flat bands.

### Conclusions:
- **Flat bands under zero total magnetic flux**: Although perfect flat bands are impossible in a non - uniform magnetic field with zero total magnetic flux, highly degenerate energy levels can be achieved by introducing non - Abelian components (spin field), thereby achieving localization.
- **"Magic" values**: Flat bands only appear at certain specific magnetic field values, which are called "magic" values, corresponding to the magnetic flux in each magnetic cell being an integer multiple of the magnetic flux quantum.
- **Application prospects**: These results not only help to understand the flat - band phenomenon in bilayer graphene and TMDs, but also provide new ideas for studying the fractional quantum Hall state in interacting systems.

Through these studies, the author provides a theoretical basis for understanding and designing new materials with flat bands.