A Generic Topological Criterion for Flat Bands in Two Dimensions

Alireza Parhizkar,Victor Galitski

2024-03-22

Abstract:We show that the continuum limit of moiré graphene is described by a $(2+1)$-dimensional field theory of Dirac fermions coupled to two classical vector fields: a periodic gauge and spin field. We further show that the existence of a flat band implies an effective dimensional reduction, where the time dimension is ``removed.'' The resulting two-dimensional Euclidean theory contains the chiral anomaly. The associated Atiyah-Singer index theorem provides a self-consistency condition for flat bands. In the Abelian limit, where the spin field is disregarded, we reproduce a periodic series of quantized magic angles known to exist in twisted bilayer graphene in the chiral limit. However, the results are not exact. If the Abelian field has zero total flux, perfectly flat bands can not exist, because of the leakage of edge states into neighboring triangular patches with opposite field orientations. We demonstrate that the non-Abelian spin component can correct this and completely flatten the bands via an effective renormalization of the Abelian component into a configuration with a non-zero total flux. We present the Abelianization of the theory where the Abelianized flat band can be mapped to that of the lowest Landau level. We show that the Abelianization corrects the values of the magic angles consistent with numerical results. We also use this criterion to prove that an external magnetic field splits the series into pairs of magnetic field-dependent magic angles associated with flat moiré-Landau bands. The topological criterion and the Abelianization procedure provide a generic practical method for finding flat bands in a variety of material systems including but not limited to moiré bilayers.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons,High Energy Physics - Theory,Mathematical Physics,Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to explore the general topological criteria for the emergence of flat bands in two - dimensional materials. Specifically, the authors studied the electronic structure of bilayer graphene under small - angle twisting or strain, and proposed a theoretical framework to explain the existence of flat bands and their topological properties.

#### Main problems and methods

1. **Existence conditions of flat bands**:
- The authors showed that the existence of flat bands implies an effective dimension reduction, that is, "removing" the time dimension to obtain a two - dimensional Euclidean theory.
- This two - dimensional theory contains chiral anomaly, and the related Atiyah - Singer index theorem provides a self - consistent condition to determine whether flat bands exist.

2. **Abelian limit and magic angle**:
- In the Abelian limit (ignoring the spin field), the authors reproduced the known quantized magic - angle sequence in bilayer graphene.
- However, if the total flux of the Abelian field is zero, a completely flat band cannot exist because edge states will leak into adjacent triangular regions with opposite field directions.

3. **Non - Abelian correction**:
- The authors proved that the non - Abelian spin - field component can completely flatten the energy band by effectively renormalizing the Abelian component so that its configuration has a non - zero total flux.
- Through the Abelianization process, the Abelianized flat band is mapped to the lowest Landau level, and the value of the magic angle is corrected to be consistent with the numerical results.

4. **Influence of external magnetic field**:
- The authors also used this criterion to prove that the external magnetic field will split the magic - angle sequence into magnetic - dependent magic - angle pairs, which are related to flat bands.

5. **Application of topological criteria**:
- The proposed topological criteria and Abelianization procedure provide a general and practical method for finding flat bands in various material systems (including but not limited to moiré bilayers).

#### Mathematical expressions

- **Classical vector field coupled with Dirac fermions**:
\[
H=\int d^{2}x\left[\bar{\psi}i\nu\gamma_{a}(\partial_{a}+iA_{a}\gamma_{5}+iS_{a}\gamma_{3})\psi-\bar{\psi}\gamma_{0}A_{0}\gamma_{5}\psi-\bar{\psi}\gamma_{0}S_{0}i\gamma_{3}\psi\right]
\]

- **Relationship between magnetic flux and magic angle**:
\[
n_{\rightarrow}=\frac{1}{4\pi}\int d^{2}x\epsilon^{ab}\partial_{a}A_{b}=\frac{3\sqrt{3}u}{4\pi\nu L}
\]
When \(n_{\rightarrow} = 1\), the first magic angle is obtained:
\[
L = L_{0}=\frac{4\pi\nu}{3\sqrt{3}u}
\]
where \(L_{0}\) is the lattice constant corresponding to the magic angle without an external magnetic field.

#### Summary

This paper proposes a general topological criterion to describe the flat - band phenomenon in two - dimensional materials by introducing the coupling of Dirac fermions and classical vector fields. In particular, the authors analyzed in detail the electronic structure of bilayer graphene under different conditions (such as twisting, strain, external magnetic field, etc.), and provided theoretical basis and calculation methods for the existence of flat bands. This not only helps to understand the strongly correlated phases in bilayer graphene, but also provides new ideas and tools for the research of other two - dimensional material systems.