Abstract:Proximity-based cities have attracted much attention in recent years. The 15-minute city, in particular, heralded a new vision for cities where essential services must be easily accessible. Despite its undoubted merit in stimulating discussion on new organisations of cities, the 15-minute city cannot be applicable everywhere, and its very definition raises a few concerns. Here, we tackle the feasibility and practicability of the '15-minute city' model in many cities worldwide. We provide a worldwide quantification of how close cities are to the ideal of the 15-minute city. To this end, we measure the accessibility times to resources and services, and we reveal strong heterogeneity of accessibility within and across cities, with a significant role played by local population densities. We provide an online platform (\href{<a class="link-external link-http" href="http://whatif.sonycsl.it/15mincity" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a>}{<a class="link-external link-http" href="http://whatif.sonycsl.it/15mincity" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a>}) to access and visualise accessibility scores for virtually all cities worldwide. The heterogeneity of accessibility within cities is one of the sources of inequality. We thus simulate how much a better redistribution of resources and services could heal inequity by keeping the same resources and services or by allowing for virtually infinite resources. We highlight pronounced discrepancies among cities in the minimum number of additional services needed to comply with the 15-minute city concept. We conclude that the proximity-based paradigm must be generalised to work on a wide range of local population densities. Finally, socio-economic and cultural factors should be included to shift from time-based to value-based cities.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem this paper attempts to address is the assessment of the feasibility and practicality of the "15-minute city" model in different cities around the world, and to propose an optimization scheme to improve the distribution of resources and services in cities to reduce inequality. Specifically: 1. **Assessing the current proximity of cities to the 15-minute city model**: The paper quantitatively analyzes the current state of multiple cities globally, revealing significant differences in accessibility within and between cities. The study shows that city centers usually have better service accessibility than peripheral areas, but this pattern is not universally applicable. For example, cities like Paris and Barcelona have achieved relatively balanced service distribution under policy promotion. 2. **Exploring the practical application challenges of the 15-minute city concept**: Although the 15-minute city concept is attractive, its implementation faces many challenges, including the impact of urban density and population distribution. The paper points out that low-density cities (such as Atlanta in the United States) may require an extremely high number of service points to achieve the 15-minute city goal, which may be difficult to achieve in practice. 3. **Proposing an algorithm to optimize service distribution**: To alleviate inequality within cities, the paper develops an algorithm to redistribute existing points of interest (POIs) so that the population in each area can enjoy relatively equal services. Through simulation experiments, the paper demonstrates the potential of this algorithm in improving overall city accessibility and reducing inequality. 4. **Exploring paths to achieve inclusive 15-minute cities**: The paper further explores how to increase the number of service points and optimize their distribution so that more urban residents can enjoy services within 15 minutes. The study finds that high-density and evenly distributed cities (such as Mumbai and Bogotá) are relatively easy to achieve this goal, while low-density or dispersed cities face greater challenges. In summary, this paper not only provides an in-depth analysis of the feasibility of the 15-minute city model on a global scale but also proposes specific solutions aimed at promoting more equitable and sustainable urban planning.

A universal framework for inclusive 15-minute cities

Is proximity enough? A critical analysis of a 15-minute city considering individual perceptions

Towards a 15-minute city: A network-based evaluation framework

Developing a 15-minute city: A comparative study of four Italian Cities-Cagliari, Perugia, Pisa, and Trieste

The 15-Minute City: An Attempt to Measure Proximity to Urban Services in Rome

Cities beyond proximity

Compact 15-minute cities are greener

Exploring the 15-minute neighbourhoods. An evaluation based on the walkability performance to public facilities

The Theoretical, Practical, and Technological Foundations of the 15-Minute City Model: Proximity and Its Environmental, Social and Economic Benefits for Sustainability

The 15-minute city quantified using human mobility data

Time, the other dimension of urban form: Measuring the relationship between urban density and accessibility to grocery shops in the 10-minute city

Practical Framework for Benchmarking and Impact Evaluation of Public Transportation Infrastructure: Case of Belo Horizonte, Brazil

15-minute Cities: a literature overview exploring international planning strategies

Advancing Health Equity through 15-min Cities and Chrono-urbanism

The ‘15-Minute City’ concept can shape a net-zero urban future

15-Minute City: Decomposing the New Urban Planning Eutopia

The X-Minute City: Analysing Accessibility to Essential Daily Destinations by Active Mobility in Seville

A city of cities: Measuring how 15-minutes urban accessibility shapes human mobility in Barcelona

City composition and accessibility statistics in and around Paris

Walkability defined neighborhoods for sustainable cities

Unravelling the Spatial Arrangement of the 15-Minute City: A Comparative Study of Shanghai, Melbourne, and Portland