Abstract:We use the Survey of Thermodynamic Processes and First and Second Laws-Long (STPFaSL-Long), a research-based survey instrument with 78 items at the level of introductory physics, to investigate introductory and advanced students' difficulties with entropy and the second law of thermodynamics. We present analysis of data from 12 different introductory and advanced physics classes at four different higher education public institutions in the US in which the survey was administered in-person to more than 1000 students. We find that a widespread unproductive tendency for introductory students to associate the properties of entropy with those of energy leads to many errors based on an idea of "conservation of entropy," in which entropy increases are always balanced by equal entropy decreases. For many of the more advanced students (calculus-based and upper level), we detect a tendency to expect entropy increases even in processes in which the entropy does not change. We observed a widespread failure to correctly apply the relationship {\Delta}S = {\delta}Qreversible/T, either by using it for irreversible processes to which it does not apply, or by applying it incorrectly or completely neglecting it in reversible processes to which it does apply. We also noted that many introductory students are simply not aware that total entropy must increase in any "spontaneous" heat transfer process. Students at all levels were very frequently found to be confused that while net entropy (system + reservoir) in reversible isothermal processes does not change, the entropy of the working substance itself does indeed increase or decrease depending on whether the process is an expansion or compression. Our findings are broadly consistent with prior research findings in this area, expanding upon them and revealing previously unreported aspects of students' thinking.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the difficulties encountered by beginners and advanced students in understanding thermodynamic entropy and the second law. The authors used a validated research tool, the "Survey of Thermodynamic Processes and the First and Second Laws" (STPFaSL-Long), to survey over 1000 students from 12 different classes at four different public higher education institutions in the United States. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following issues: 1. **Common Misconceptions of Beginners**: - Beginners tend to confuse the properties of entropy with those of energy, leading them to mistakenly believe that entropy is conserved, i.e., an increase in entropy is always accompanied by an equal decrease in entropy. - Many beginners are unaware that in any spontaneous heat transfer process, the total entropy must increase. 2. **Common Misconceptions of Advanced Students**: - Advanced students (including those in calculus-based and higher-level courses) tend to believe that entropy increases even in processes where entropy remains constant. - Students have difficulty applying the formula \( \Delta S = \frac{\delta Q_{\text{rev}}}{T} \), either applying it to irreversible processes or completely ignoring or misapplying this formula in reversible processes. - Many students confuse the concepts of system entropy, environmental entropy, and universal entropy (system + environment), especially when assessing entropy changes in spontaneous processes, often failing to correctly identify that the total entropy must increase. 3. **Widespread Conceptual Confusion**: - Students generally find it difficult to understand that in a reversible isothermal process, although the net entropy (system + heat reservoir) does not change, the entropy of the working substance itself does increase or decrease, depending on whether the process is expansion or compression. Through these surveys and analyses, the paper aims to reveal the specific difficulties students face regarding thermodynamic entropy and the second law and to provide a basis for improving teaching methods. These findings not only help enhance students' understanding of these fundamental thermodynamic concepts but also support the development of effective research-based teaching tools and methods.

Investigating introductory and advanced students' difficulties with entropy and the second law of thermodynamics using a validated instrument

Investigating introductory and advanced students' difficulties with change in internal energy, work and heat transfer using a validated instrument

Student understanding of the first law and second law of thermodynamics

Identifying Student Difficulties with Entropy, Heat Engines, and the Carnot Cycle

Development and Validation of a conceptual survey instrument to evaluate introductory physics students' understanding of thermodynamics

Development and validation of a conceptual multiple-choice survey instrument to assess student understanding of introductory thermodynamics

Entropy and spontaneity in an introductory physics course for life science students

Introducing the second law of thermodynamics using Legitimation Code Theory among first year chemistry students

Helping Pregraduate Students Reach Deep Understanding of the Second Law of Thermodynamics

Investigating graduate student reasoning on a conceptual entropy questionnaire

Using the Energy and Momentum Conceptual Survey to investigate progression in student understanding from introductory to advanced levels

Thermodynamics in Context: A Case Study of Contextualized Teaching for Undergraduates

Development of a representational conceptual evaluation in the first law of thermodynamics

Second Law of Thermodynamics and the Criterion for the Possible Process

Energy conservation in dissipative processes: Teacher expectations and strategies associated with imperceptible thermal energy

Microcanonical Statistical Mechanics of a Nonideal Fluid: A Pedagogical Approach to Obtain the Combined First and Second Law of Thermodynamics

The Second Law and Entropy Misconceptions Demystified

Introduction to the Thermodynamics of Materials

Revisiting The Second Law of Energy Degradation and Entropy Generation: From Sadi Carnot's Ingenious Reasoning to Holistic Generalization

Student understanding of Fermi energy, the Fermi-Dirac distribution and total electronic energy of a free electron gas

Large-deviation principles, stochastic effective actions, path entropies, and the structure and meaning of thermodynamic descriptions