Jan Korbel,David H. Wolpert
Abstract:In the real world, one almost never knows the parameters of a thermodynamic process to infinite precision. Reflecting this, here we investigate how to extend stochastic thermodynamics to systems with uncertain parameters, including uncertain number of heat baths / particle reservoirs, uncertainty in the precise values of temperatures / chemical potentials of those reservoirs, uncertainty in the energy spectrum, uncertainty in the control protocol, etc. We formalize such uncertainty with an (arbitrary) probability measure over all transition rate matrices satisfying local detailed balance. This lets us define the effective thermodynamic quantities by averaging over all LDB-obeying rate matrices. We show that the resultant effective entropy violates the second law of thermodynamics. In contrast to the effective entropy though, the expected stochastic entropy, defined as the ensemble average of the effective trajectory-level entropy, satisfies the second law. We then and explicitly calculate the second-order correction to the second law for the case of one heat bath with uncertain temperature. We also derive the detailed fluctuation theorem for expected effective trajectory entropy production for this case, and derive a lower bound for the associated expected work. Next, to ground these formal considerations with experimentally testable bounds on allowed energetics, we derive a bound on the maximal work that can be extracted from systems with arbitrarily uncertain temperature. We end by extending previous work on "thermodynamic value of information", to allow for uncertainty in the time-evolution of the rate matrix.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to extend the stochastic thermodynamics theory to describe the non - equilibrium thermodynamic properties of these systems in actual systems due to the uncertainty of parameters (such as temperature, chemical potential, energy spectrum, etc.). Specifically, the author explores how to define effective thermodynamic quantities in the presence of uncertain parameters and analyzes the relationship between these quantities and the traditional laws of thermodynamics.
### Main problems:
1. **The influence of parameter uncertainty on thermodynamics**:
- In actual systems, parameters (such as temperature, chemical potential, energy spectrum, etc.) are often not known precisely. How does this uncertainty affect the thermodynamic behavior of the system?
- How to extend the stochastic thermodynamics theory in the presence of parameter uncertainty?
2. **Definition of effective thermodynamic quantities**:
- How to define and calculate thermodynamic quantities such as effective entropy and effective heat?
- Do these effective thermodynamic quantities still satisfy the traditional laws of thermodynamics (such as the second law)?
3. **Analysis of specific cases**:
- When the system is connected to a heat reservoir with an uncertain temperature, how to calculate the effective entropy flow and the effective heat flow?
- How to derive the detailed fluctuation theorem and the lower bound of the work?
### Specific content:
- **Introducing uncertainty**:
- The author quantifies the uncertainty of parameters by introducing a probability measure \(dF_K\), where \(K\) is the transition rate matrix that satisfies the local detailed balance condition.
- Through this probability measure, various effective thermodynamic quantities can be defined, such as effective probability distribution, effective internal energy, effective entropy, etc.
- **Effective entropy and the second law**:
- The author finds that the effective entropy does not always satisfy the second law, that is, its time derivative may not always be non - negative.
- However, the "expected stochastic entropy" defined as the expected value of the trajectory - level effective entropy still satisfies the second law.
- **Specific case: a single heat reservoir**:
- When the system is connected to a heat reservoir with an uncertain temperature, the author derives the expressions of the effective entropy flow and the effective heat flow.
- Through the second - order expansion, the author calculates the correction terms of the effective entropy flow and discusses the influence of these correction terms on the second law.
- **Detailed fluctuation theorem**:
- The author derives the detailed fluctuation theorem of the expected trajectory entropy production and gives the lower bound of the related work.
- These results are helpful for understanding the non - equilibrium behavior of the system in the presence of parameter uncertainty.
### Conclusion:
This paper extends the stochastic thermodynamics theory by introducing parameter uncertainty and explores the effective thermodynamic properties of the system in this case. The author finds that although the effective entropy may not satisfy the second law, the expected stochastic entropy still satisfies the second law. In addition, the paper also provides specific calculation methods and case analysis, which provides a theoretical basis for understanding and dealing with parameter uncertainty in actual systems.