Large Eddy Simulations of Flow over Additively Manufactured Surfaces: Impact of Roughness and Skewness on Turbulent Heat Transfer

Himani Garg,Guillaume Sahut,Erika Tuneskog,Karl-Johan Nogenmyr,Christer Fureby

2024-06-08

Abstract:Additive manufacturing creates surfaces with random roughness, impacting heat transfer and pressure loss differently than traditional sand-grain roughness. We conducted high-fidelity heat transfer simulations over three-dimensional additive manufactured surfaces with varying roughness heights and skewness. Based on an additive manufactured Inconel 939 sample from Siemens Energy AB, we created six surfaces with different normalized roughness heights, $R_a/D = 0.001, 0.006, 0.012, 0.015, 0.020,$ and $0.028$, and a fixed skewness, ${s_k} = 0.424$. Each surface was also flipped to obtain negatively skewed counterparts (${s_k} = -0.424)$. Simulations were conducted at a constant Reynolds number of 8000 and with temperature treated as a passive scalar. We analyzed temperature, velocity profiles and heat fluxes to understand the impact of roughness height and skewness on heat and momentum transfer. The inner-scaled mean temperature profiles are of larger magnitude than the mean velocity profiles both inside and outside the roughness layer. This means the temperature wall roughness function differs from the momentum wall roughness function. Surfaces with positive and negative skewness yielded different estimates of equivalent sand-grain roughness for the same $R_a/D$ values, suggesting a strong influence of slope and skewness on the relationship between roughness function and equivalent sand-grain roughness. Analysis of the heat and momentum transfer mechanisms indicated an increased effective Prandtl number within the rough surface in which the momentum diffusivity is larger than the corresponding thermal diffusivity due to the combined effects of turbulence and dispersion. Results consistently indicated improved heat transfer with increasing roughness height and positively skewed surfaces performing better beyond a certain roughness threshold than negatively skewed ones.

Fluid Dynamics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems Addressed by the Paper

This paper aims to investigate the impact of surface roughness in additive manufacturing (AM) on turbulent heat transfer. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following points:

1. **Impact of Surface Roughness**: Surfaces produced by additive manufacturing techniques (such as Laser Powder Bed Fusion, PBF-LB) have random roughness, which differs from traditional sand grain roughness and affects heat transfer and pressure loss differently. Therefore, further research on these impacts is needed.

2. **Role of Roughness Height and Skewness**: The paper studies three-dimensional additive manufacturing surfaces with different roughness heights (Ra/D) and skewness (sk) through high-fidelity heat transfer simulations. Specifically, the authors created six different surfaces with normalized roughness heights of 0.001, 0.006, 0.012, 0.015, 0.020, and 0.028, with a fixed skewness of 0.424. Corresponding surfaces with negative skewness (sk=-0.424) were obtained by flipping the surfaces.

3. **Mechanisms of Heat and Momentum Transfer**: By analyzing temperature, velocity profiles, and heat flux, the paper explores the effects of roughness height and skewness on heat and momentum transfer. The study finds that surfaces with increased roughness height and positive skewness exhibit better heat transfer performance beyond a certain threshold.

4. **Relationship of Equivalent Sand Grain Roughness**: The paper examines the different estimates of equivalent sand grain roughness for surfaces with positive and negative skewness at the same Ra/D values, indicating a strong influence of slope and skewness on the relationship between roughness function and equivalent sand grain roughness.

5. **Variation of Effective Prandtl Number**: The analysis of heat and momentum transfer mechanisms reveals that within rough surfaces, due to the combined effects of turbulence and dispersion, the momentum diffusivity is greater than the corresponding thermal diffusivity, leading to an increase in the effective Prandtl number.

In summary, through detailed numerical simulations and analysis, this paper explores the impact of surface roughness in additive manufacturing on turbulent heat transfer, providing important references for designing efficient cooling systems.