Changes in boiling controlled by molar concentration-dependent diffusion of surfactants

Mario R. Mata,Matic Može,Armin Hadžić,Giseop Lee,Blake Naccarato,Isaac Berk,Iztok Golobič,H. Jeremy Cho

2024-06-05

Abstract:Boiling is a prevalent phase-change process that plays a vital role in facilitating efficient heat transfer from a heating surface. While this heat transfer mechanism is generally effective, a rapid increase in surface temperature can lead to hydrodynamic instabilities, resulting in a boiling crisis. Previous studies have shown that surfactants often improve boiling performance and change the boiling crisis behavior. Conventional wisdom in this field attributes that these changes in boiling behavior are tied to the critical micelle concentration (CMC) of the particular surfactant. However, our work reveals that these changes in boiling behavior are independent of the CMC for three nonionic surfactants across a wide range of molar concentrations. In addition, visual snapshots of the bubbling behavior indicate changes in bubble formation, such as bubble size and nucleation site density, influenced by the molar concentration-dependent diffusion timescale of surfactants. Hence, these findings offer compelling evidence that boiling behavior, encompassing both boiling performance and boiling crisis, is governed by the dynamic adsorption of surfactants rather than dictated by the CMC. This becomes evident when quantifying the heat transfer coefficient (HTC) and critical heat flux (CHF) using the logarithm of molar concentration, as predicted by theory. Building upon these findings, we propose insights for controlling when CHF modification occurs in specific scenarios involving any surfactants. These insights hold significant potential for optimizing heat transfer processes and leveraging surfactants in energy-related applications to maximize boiling efficiency.

Fluid Dynamics,Materials Science,Applied Physics,Chemical Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is: the impact of surfactants on boiling behavior and its mechanisms.

Specifically, the paper explores the following points:
1. **The impact of surfactants on boiling performance**: The study found that the adsorption kinetics of surfactants (rather than their critical micelle concentration, CMC) control boiling behavior. At different molar concentrations, the effect of surfactants on the heat transfer coefficient (HTC) and critical heat flux (CHF) shows similar trends.
2. **Changes in boiling crisis**: The paper points out that different types of surfactants exhibit similar changes in boiling behavior at the same molar concentration, indicating that the changes in boiling behavior are related to the dynamic adsorption of surfactants rather than their CMC.
3. **The impact of dynamic adsorption on boiling behavior**: Through experiments and modeling, the paper reveals the relationship between the diffusion time scale (tdiff) of surfactants and the bubble lifecycle (tb). When tdiff is close to or less than tb, the adsorption of surfactants significantly increases, leading to changes in bubble behavior, such as bubble size, nucleation site density, and non-coalescence phenomena.

In summary, this paper aims to elucidate how the dynamic adsorption of surfactants affects boiling performance and proposes a new understanding that boiling behavior is primarily controlled by the dynamic adsorption process of surfactants, rather than just their CMC. This finding is significant for optimizing heat transfer processes and improving boiling efficiency.