Implications of in-ice volume scattering for radio-frequency neutrino experiments

A. Nozdrina,D. Besson

2024-09-30

Abstract:Over the last three decades, several experimental initiatives have been launched with the goal of observing radio-frequency signals produced by ultra-high energy neutrinos (UHEN) interacting in solid media. Observed neutrino event signatures comprise impulsive signals with duration of order the inverse of the antenna+system bandwidth ($\sim$10 ns), superimposed upon an incoherent (typically white noise) thermal noise spectrum. Whereas bulk volume scattering (VS) of radio-frequency (RF) signals is well-studied within the radio-glaciological communities, polar ice-based neutrino-detection experiments have thus far neglected VS in their signal projections. As discussed herein, coherent volume scattering (CVS, for which the phase of the incident signal is preserved during scattering) generated by in-ice neutrino interactions may similarly produce short-duration signal-like power, albeit with a slightly extended time structure, and thereby enhance neutrino detection rates, whereas incoherent (randomized phase) volume scattering (IVS) will persist for O(100 ns), appearing similar to thermal white noise and therefore reducing the measured Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) of neutrino signals. Herein, we present the expected voltage profiles resulting from in-ice volume scattering as a function of the molecular scattering cross-section, for both CVS and IVS, and assess their impact on UHEN experiments. VS contributions are currently only weakly constrained by extant data; stronger limits may be obtained with dedicated calibration experiments.

Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper mainly explores the impact of volume scattering (VS) in ice on radio - frequency - based ultra - high - energy neutrino (UHEN) experiments. Specifically, the author attempts to solve the following key problems:

1. **The impact of volume scattering on neutrino signal detection**:
- **Coherent Volume Scattering (CVS)**: This scattering preserves the phase of the incident signal and produces a power enhancement similar to the signal in a short time, which may increase the neutrino detection rate.
- **Incoherent Volume Scattering (IVS)**: This scattering randomizes the phase and has a relatively long duration (about 100 nanoseconds), similar to thermal noise, thus reducing the signal - to - noise ratio (SNR) and affecting the detection of neutrino signals.

2. **Deficiencies in existing experiments**:
- Current polar ice - based neutrino detection experiments ignore the impact of volume scattering in signal prediction. By studying volume scattering, the design and performance of these experiments can be more accurately evaluated and improved.

3. **Theoretical models and simulations of volume scattering**:
- The paper uses the Monte Carlo simulation software `nuradiomc` to evaluate the impact of volume scattering on neutrino waveforms under different scattering cross - sections. These simulations help determine the potential contribution of volume scattering to neutrino signals and provide new data constraints.

4. **Experimental verification**:
- Use the data analysis of the RICE experiment to study the possible volume scattering effects. In particular, the impact of incoherent volume scattering is quantified by comparing the time structures before and after the calibration pulse signal.

### Formula summary

- **Complex permittivity of the Drude - Lorentz oscillator model**:
\[
\epsilon_r = 1+\frac{\omega_p^2}{\omega_0^2-\omega^2 - i\omega\gamma}
\]
where \(\omega_p=\sqrt{\frac{Nq^2}{m\epsilon_0}}\) is the plasma frequency and \(\gamma\) is the collision damping coefficient.

- **Upper limit estimate of volume scattering cross - section**:
\[
\sigma_{VS}\leq3.7\times 10^{-28}\text{cm}^2
\]

- **The impact of CVS and IVS on signal amplitude**:
- The signal amplitude enhancement caused by CVS is approximately 1% and lasts slightly longer than the main signal.
- The increase in background noise caused by IVS is less than 0.1%.

### Conclusion

Through the above research, the author points out that volume scattering (especially incoherent volume scattering) has a significant impact on neutrino signal detection and needs to be considered in future experiment designs. At the same time, further experiments and simulations can help to better understand and constrain the characteristics of volume scattering, thereby improving the sensitivity and accuracy of neutrino detection.