Modeling the refractive index profile n(z) of polar ice for ultra-high energy neutrino experiments

S. Ali,P. Allison,S. Archambault,J.J. Beatty,D.Z. Besson,A. Bishop,P. Chen,Y.C. Chen,B.A. Clark,W. Clay,A. Connolly,K. Couberly,L. Cremonesi,A. Cummings,P. Dasgupta,R. Debolt,S. de Kockere,K.D. de Vries,C. Deaconu,M. A. DuVernois,J. Flaherty,E. Friedman,R. Gaior,P. Giri,J. Hanson,N. Harty,K.D. Hoffman,J.J. Huang,M.-H. Huang,K. Hughes,A. Ishihara,A. Karle,J.L. Kelley,K.-C. Kim,M.-C. Kim,I. Kravchenko,R. Krebs,C.Y. Kuo,K. Kurusu,U.A. Latif,C.H Liu,T.C. Liu,W. Luszczak,K. Mase,M.S. Muzio,J. Nam,R.J. Nichol,A. Novikov,A. Nozdrina,E. Oberla,Y. Pan,C. Pfendner,N. Punsuebsay,J. Roth,A. Salcedo-Gomez,D. Seckel,M.F.H. Seikh,Y.-S. Shaio,D. Smith,S. Toscano,J. Torres,J. Touart,N. van Eijndhoven,A. Vieregg,M.-Z. Wang,S.-H. Wang,S.A. Wissel,C. Xie,S. Yoshida,R. Young

2024-06-12

Abstract:We develop an in-situ index of refraction profile using the transit time of radio signals broadcast from an englacial transmitter to 2-5 km distant radio-frequency receivers, deployed at depths up to 200 m. Maxwell's equations generally admit two ray propagation solutions from a given transmitter, corresponding to a direct path (D) and a refracted path (R); the measured D vs. R (dt(D,R)) timing differences provide constraints on the index of refraction profile near South Pole, where the Askaryan Radio Array (ARA) neutrino observatory is located. We constrain the refractive index profile by simulating D and R ray paths via ray tracing and comparing those to measured dt(D,R) signals. Using previous ice density data as a proxy for n(z), we demonstrate that our data strongly favors a glaciologically-motivated three-phase densification model rather than a single exponential scale height model. Simulations show that the single exponential model overestimates ARA neutrino sensitivity compared to the three-phase model.

Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problem does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to solve the problem of accurate modeling of the refractive index distribution \(n(z)\) in the Antarctic ice sheet in order to improve the sensitivity and accuracy of the Ultra - High - Energy Neutrino (UHEN) experiment. Specifically, the research objectives include:

1. **Accurately measure and model the refractive index distribution in the ice sheet**:
- Researchers constrain the refractive index distribution \(n(z)\) of the ice sheet by analyzing the radio - wave propagation time difference \(dt(D, R)\) from the emitter inside the ice sheet to the receiver.
- They compare the single - exponential model and the three - stage exponential model. The latter is based on the multi - stage characteristics of the ice - sheet density varying with depth.

2. **Verify and improve the existing refractive index models**:
- The single - exponential model assumes that the refractive index of the ice sheet decays exponentially with depth, while the three - stage model takes into account the different physical states of the ice sheet at different depths (such as snow, ice crystals, ice with bubbles) and fits the refractive index in these regions respectively.
- The study finds that the three - stage model fits the experimental data better than the single - exponential model, especially in the ice - with - bubbles region.

3. **Evaluate the impact of different models on experimental sensitivity**:
- The research shows that the single - exponential model overestimates the sensitivity of the UHEN experiment, while the three - stage model provides a more accurate estimate, resulting in a lower effective detection volume and a slightly lower expected neutrino detection rate.
- This result is helpful for choosing a more appropriate refractive index model in future experiment design and data analysis.

4. **Correct the antenna depth change caused by snow accumulation**:
- Researchers also consider the influence of snow accumulation in Antarctica over the years on the antenna depth and correct it through long - term monitoring data to ensure the accuracy of the measurement results.

### Summary

By accurately measuring and modeling the refractive index distribution of the Antarctic ice sheet, this paper overcomes the limitations of existing models and provides more accurate physical parameters for the Ultra - High - Energy Neutrino experiment, thereby improving the sensitivity and reliability of the experiment.