Isotopic evidence of long-lived volcanism on Io

Katherine de Kleer,Ery C. Hughes,Francis Nimmo,John Eiler,Amy E. Hofmann,Statia Luszcz-Cook,Kathy Mandt

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adj0625

2024-05-29

Abstract:Jupiter's moon Io hosts extensive volcanism driven by tidal heating. The isotopic composition of Io's inventory of volatile elements, including sulfur and chlorine, reflects its outgassing and mass loss history and provides an avenue for exploring its evolution. We used millimeter observations of Io's atmosphere to measure sulfur isotopes in gaseous SO2 and SO, and chlorine isotopes in gaseous NaCl and KCl. We find $^{34}$S/$^{32}$S=0.0595$\pm$0.0038 ($\delta^{34}$S=+347$\pm$86 per mille), which is highly enriched compared to average Solar System values and indicates that Io has lost 94 to 99% of its available sulfur. Our measurement of $^{37}$Cl/$^{35}$Cl=0.403$\pm$0.028 ($\delta^{37}$Cl=+263$\pm$88 per mille) shows chlorine is similarly enriched. These measurements indicate that Io has been volcanically active for most or all of its history, with potentially higher outgassing and mass-loss rates at earlier times.

Earth and Planetary Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper mainly discusses the isotopic evidence of long-term volcanic activity on Jupiter's moon, Io. The volcanic activity on Io is driven by tidal heating, which may have been continuous or periodic since the formation of the solar system. Through millimeter wave observations, researchers measured the isotopic composition of sulfur and chlorine in Io's atmosphere to understand its volcanic history and mass loss.

The study found that the sulfur isotope ratio 34S/32S in Io is significantly higher than the average level in the solar system, indicating that Io has lost most of its available sulfur (94% to 99%). The chlorine isotope ratio 37Cl/35Cl also shows similar enrichment. These measurement results suggest that Io has maintained volcanic activity for most or all of its history, with possibly higher gas and mass loss rates in the early stages.

Modeling analysis of Io's atmosphere suggests that isotopic fractionation processes have led to this enrichment, with lighter isotopes preferentially lost during volcanic cycling and atmospheric escape. They propose that if Io's current mass loss rate (1000 to 3000 kilograms per second) has been sustained for billions of years, then it should have already lost most of its sulfur inventory, which is inconsistent with actual observations. This may imply that Io's past mass loss rate was higher than the current rate, or that only a fraction of the sulfur participated in the cycling and loss process, such as being concentrated in the core.

In addition, the chlorine isotope data from Io also support a history of ongoing volcanic activity. The loss process of chlorine is also influenced by atmospheric stratification, but the uncertainty of its isotopic fractionation factor is higher than that of sulfur.

In conclusion, this paper attempts to address the following questions: how is Io's long-term volcanic activity reflected by isotopic evidence, and how do these isotopic measurements reveal patterns of Io's volcanic history, surface rejuvenation, and mass loss.