Simulation of perovskite thin layer crystallization with varying evaporation rates

M. Majewski,S. Qiu,O. Ronsin,L. Lüer,V. M. Le Corre,T. Du,C. J. Brabec,H.-J. Egelhaaf,J. Harting
2024-10-31
Abstract:Perovskite solar cells (PSC) are promising potential competitors to established photovoltaic technologies due to their superior efficiency and low-cost solution processability. However, the limited understanding of the crystallization behaviour hinders the technological transition from lab-scale cells to modules. In this work, we perform Phase Field (PF) simulations of the doctor-bladed film formation to obtain mechanistic and morphological information that is experimentally challenging to access. PF simulations are validated extensively using in- and ex-situ experiments for different solvent evaporation rates. The well-known transition from a film with many pinholes, for a low evaporation rate, to a smooth film, for high evaporation rates, is recovered in simulation and experiment. From the simulation, the transition can be assigned to the change in the ratio of evaporation to crystallization rate because of two distinct mechanisms. Firstly, for larger evaporation rates, nuclei appear at higher concentrations, which favors nucleation as compared to growth. Secondly, the growth of the crystals is confined in a thinner film, which limits their vertical size. Both effects are expected to be valid independent of the specific chemistry of the chosen experimental system, as long as the evaporation time of the solvent is comparable to the crystallization time.
Materials Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the influencing factors of the crystallization behavior of perovskite thin films during solution processing, especially the impact of evaporation rate on the final film morphology and quality. Specifically: 1. **Enhancing the understanding of the crystallization process**: Currently, there is insufficient understanding of the physical mechanisms (including evaporation, nucleation, growth, and mass transport) in the crystallization process of perovskite materials (such as methylammonium lead iodide, MAPbI₃), especially in the one - step solution - processing process. This limits the transition from laboratory - scale to large - scale production of industrial modules. 2. **Optimizing film morphology to improve device performance**: The efficiency of perovskite solar cells (PSC) is strongly influenced by the morphology of the active layer. In order to achieve high - performance perovskite solar cells, better control of film morphology is required to reduce problems such as pinholes and surface roughness. 3. **Establishing a theoretical framework**: Existing models cannot comprehensively describe the formation paths of solution - processed perovskite thin films, especially key features such as spatial organization, roughness, crystal stacking, and uncovered substrates. Therefore, a theoretical framework based on physical phenomena is needed to explain the influence of process parameters on the final morphology. 4. **Verifying and applying simulation results**: Through phase - field (PF) simulations combined with in - situ and ex - situ experimental measurements, verify and gain in - depth understanding of the film formation mechanism. These simulations can help reveal the crystallization behavior at different evaporation rates and provide guidance for improving the process of large - scale production. ### Core problems of the paper - **The influence of evaporation rate on film morphology**: The paper studies the influence of changing the evaporation rate (for example, through gas quenching) on the final film morphology (such as roughness, grain size, number of pinholes, etc.). - **The physical mechanism of the crystallization process**: Explore how the high supersaturation and crystallization - limiting effects caused by high evaporation rates determine the final film morphology. - **The ratio of evaporation to crystallization rate**: Research shows that the ratio of evaporation rate to crystallization rate is a key parameter in determining the final film morphology. Increasing this ratio can improve film quality. ### Main conclusions Through PF simulations and experimental verification, the paper demonstrates the significant influence of the evaporation rate on the perovskite film morphology and proposes a method to optimize film quality by adjusting the evaporation rate. This provides theoretical and technical support for the development of high - performance, all - printed perovskite solar cells.