A psychophysical evaluation of techniques for Mooney image generation

Lars C. Reining,Thomas S. A. Wallis

2024-03-18

Abstract:Mooney images can contribute to our understanding of the processes involved in visual perception, because they allow a dissociation between image content and image understanding. Mooney images are generated by first smoothing and subsequently thresholding an image. In most previous studies this was performed manually, using subjective criteria for generation. This manual process could eventually be avoided by using automatic generation techniques. The field of computer image processing offers numerous techniques for image thresholding, but these are only rarely used to create Mooney images. Furthermore, there is little research on the perceptual effects of smoothing and thresholding. Therefore, in this study we investigated how the choice of different thresholding techniques and amount of smoothing affects the interpretability of Mooney images for human participants. We generated Mooney images using four different thresholding techniques and, in a second experiment, parametrically varied the level of smoothing. Participants identified the concepts shown in Mooney images and rated their interpretability. Although the techniques generate physically-different Mooney images, identification performance and subjective ratings were similar across the different techniques. This indicates that finding the perfect threshold in the process of generating Mooney images is not critical for Mooney image interpretability, at least for globally-applied thresholds. The degree of smoothing applied before thresholding, on the other hand, requires more tuning depending on the noise of the original image and the desired interpretability of the resulting Mooney image. Future work in automatic Mooney image generation should pursue local thresholding techniques, where different thresholds are applied to image regions depending on the local image content.

Neurons and Cognition

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper primarily explores how to generate Mooney images, which are special two-tone images used for studying visual perception. Traditional Mooney images are created by manually smoothing and thresholding natural images, but this process is both subjective and time-consuming. The researchers focus on automated generation techniques, specifically the impact of different thresholding techniques and smoothing levels on the interpretability of Mooney images.

In the study, the authors used four different thresholding techniques and adjusted the smoothing levels in the second experiment. Participants were asked to identify concepts in the Mooney images and rate their interpretability. The results showed that although the physically generated images differed based on these techniques, they were similar in terms of identification performance and subjective evaluation. This suggests that finding the perfect threshold is not crucial for generating Mooney images, at least for globally applied thresholds. However, adjusting the smoothing level needs to be done based on the original image's noise and desired interpretability.

The paper also points out that future research should explore local thresholding techniques, applying different thresholds based on the local content of the images. Overall, this study aims to provide more effective methods for automated Mooney image generation, in order to enhance understanding of the visual perception process and improve standardization and reproducibility of experiments.