Abstract:Mooney images can contribute to our understanding of the processes involved in visual perception, because they allow a dissociation between image content and image understanding. Mooney images are generated by first smoothing and subsequently thresholding an image. In most previous studies this was performed manually, using subjective criteria for generation. This manual process could eventually be avoided by using automatic generation techniques. The field of computer image processing offers numerous techniques for image thresholding, but these are only rarely used to create Mooney images. Furthermore, there is little research on the perceptual effects of smoothing and thresholding. Therefore, in this study we investigated how the choice of different thresholding techniques and amount of smoothing affects the interpretability of Mooney images for human participants. We generated Mooney images using four different thresholding techniques and, in a second experiment, parametrically varied the level of smoothing. Participants identified the concepts shown in Mooney images and rated their interpretability. Although the techniques generate physically-different Mooney images, identification performance and subjective ratings were similar across the different techniques. This indicates that finding the perfect threshold in the process of generating Mooney images is not critical for Mooney image interpretability, at least for globally-applied thresholds. The degree of smoothing applied before thresholding, on the other hand, requires more tuning depending on the noise of the original image and the desired interpretability of the resulting Mooney image. Future work in automatic Mooney image generation should pursue local thresholding techniques, where different thresholds are applied to image regions depending on the local image content.

Evaluation of Human Perception Thresholds Using Knowledge-Based Pattern Recognition

Learning to Observe: Approximating Human Perceptual Thresholds for Detection of Suprathreshold Image Transformations

A psychophysical evaluation of techniques for Mooney image generation

Real-Time Knowledge-Based Processing of Images: Application of the Online NLPM Method to Perceptual Visual Analysis

Perception of complex Glass patterns through spatial summation across unique frames

Examples of Artificial Perceptions in Optical Character Recognition and Iris Recognition

Object Detection Based on Saturation of Visual Perception

Objective Estimation of Sensory Thresholds Based on Neurophysiological Parameters

Art's Hidden Topology: A window into human perception

Measuring uncertainty in human visual segmentation

A Comprehensive Survey of Multi-Level Thresholding Segmentation Methods for Image Processing

An experimental approach to decoding human reactions through mixed measurements

Low-level features predict perceived similarity for naturalistic images

How patterns of bleached rods and cones become visual perceptual experiences: a proposal

A psychophysical performance-based approach to the quality assessment of image processing algorithms.

Color from invisible patterns

Human efficiency for recognizing 3-D objects in luminance noise

Measuring Human Perception to Improve Open Set Recognition

Cognitive image processing: the time is right to recognize that the world does not rest more on turtles and elephants

Research of Perceptive Information of Image

Human Recognition Using Deep Neural Networks and Spatial Patterns of SSVEP Signals